American Idol Elvis Night- I think that the tables have turned....?
535796
I ranked the contestants before last night\n\n1. Katharine\n2. Chris\n3. Taylor\n4. Elliot\n\nAfter last night\n\n1. Elliot\n2. Taylor\n3. Katharine\n4. Chris\n\nI think Katharine will go home, although I thought her vocals were better than Chris's you just cant mess up the lyrics when your in the top 4.  We'll see though!
614759
I agree with Kevin. Meatloaf and Toni seemed like they were heavily medicated. Meatloaf just butchered the song period. I think his appearance on American Idol last night will really hurt sales of his new album. In regards to Toni Braxton, that was just an awkward and really bad performance on her part.
579896
No because if it were the previous idols wouldn't be selling as many records as they are.  And just because Chris got voted off, doesn't mean it is rigged.  I think a lot of Chris fans fell asleep when they were supposed to vote for him and that's not the show's fault. I wish Chris wouldn't have gone home, and they wouldn't kick off someone with such a huge fanbase if it were rigged.  It's not like they go "Hey, let's throw America a curve ball and send many people's favorites home!"  If anything they would send the person everyone hated home.
565001
I know that usually Taylor or Paris would be the pick, but Taylor did a little better than Paris last night.  \nI hate to think it, but maybe it is Paris' turn to leave.
577801
I was shocked that the 2 favorites, Kat and Chris were both in the bottom two, let alone that Chris got voted off.  I thought that they were the 2 that best deserved to be in the finals: Chris because he was the best from the beginning and Kat because she had made the most progress, is at least close to Chris in talent now and she has the Idol look and personality.  Chris is more of a rocker and the fans tend to shy away from them a bit.  Chris did have the disadvantage of being one of 3 guys and Kat is the only gal.  Girl fans are so divided between all the guys that it was just a matter of numbers as to the fact a guy would go this week.  I thought it was a poor choice of themes at this stage of the game to have an Elvis theme.  This was Taylor's forte and was very unfair to Kat especially, but also to Chris.  Elliot really stepped up though and he has also improved quite a bit since the beginning of the competition.  Taylor is the novelty factor and I'm shocked he is still there.  I am still hoping for Kat to win, I like her style, her abilities and her personality.
307324
Anythings possible.  The judges were all hot for her in the first few weeks.  But you know the saying..."familiarity breeds contempt."  \n\nShe may be the smartest one there if her story actually works in her favor..."I BUTCHERED THAT SONG."  I can honestly say I've never heard anyone bash themselves before. We will see if it put the final nail in her coffin.  It might as well be sooner than later.  Nice try Kellie. She's young and has a following...probably will make more records than the winner of AI.\n\nI'm sure she can be seen in Nashville at some point with the country singers...like Grand Ole' Oprey.  In fact, it almost seemed as if Bewitched, Bothered and Bewildered was her swan song. Maybe she wanted to get out of the ruthless Simon remarks made making her look like a fool each week.
380483
I don't think it is, but there was a thing on one of those 24/7 news channels about it. Something about last year when Jasmine (from Hawaii) was on there longer than she should have been. People were complaining that the time frame on voting for Hawaii was more than the 2 hours. And then they went on about speed dialing and things like that are considered cheating. \n\nBut I have thought, that maybe, the producers could have told the judges to say certain things to them to manipulate the judgment of the viewers. B/c They think, we might be thinking, "These are professionals, and if they didn't like it, then I shouldn't." Does that make since? But who knows? I don't care? They just sign another contract to do the show for 2 more seasons.... so there... to ALL THOSE AMERICAN IDOL HATERS! CHEW ON THAT!
608804
This season of American Idol is crazy-- it's hard to tell who will be in the final two now that Chris is gone. Taylor is probably a lock, as much as I care for both Elliott and Katharine; I say probably because anything could happen. \n\nIt really depends. Consistency is a major major issue with both of these, Katharine especially. Performance-wise, Elliott has done nothing but grow in the past couple of weeks. Katharine, however, started off as a favorite to win it all, but now she's slipping for one reason or another.\n\nSpeaking of the fan-base, however, Elliott has a much smaller one. The male demographic will obviously vote for Katharine, and will vote even more depending on how skimpy her dress is Tuesday night. \n\nIt's a tossup right now, but I'd put my money (or yours, rather) on Taylor vs. Elliott in the finals. I believe the whispers among the fans that say that they'll be voting for Elliott and Taylor to avenge Chris' "wrongful departure". But you never know.
557140
Chris is gone. But you know he will get a recording contract, so I don't really feel sorry for him. He got the exposure he needed. You know, the decision is based on the public votes, so evidently more people voted for the others...   that's the way it works. Tayor and Elliott really cranked it up this week. ....
578712
I hope it's McPhee... she didn't earn a spot based on last night and I think Yamin out sang her... \n\nI hope Taylor wins, but tonight... I really honestly think McPhee deserves to go... her first song was horrible... the pace was bad, the lyrics were bad, her timing was bad... she was just really off...\n\nI just hope she doesn't get to stay cause she's cute... this show needs to be based mostly on talent and although she has that in abundance, she isn't continuing to improve like the other performers.  I think she has actually been off for the last several shows.
596120
It wasn't me! I voted 173 times by phone and dial idol got through 31 times. I am so NOT HAPPY! Chris was and STILL is the MAN. Chris WILL be a BIGGER STAR than whoever ends up winning. He will sell more albums and make more money too. This, being voted out, may not be a bad thing for Chris. He will not be under a contract with American Idol when he makes his album and will pocket more money than the actual winner will. CHRIS ROCKS!!!!!
565546
Chris was the only one who's progress I paid attention to, so I was shocked and disappointed at first...not so much anymore...cuz the boy has got it.  I'm sure you know by now that Fuel has offered him a spot singing for them.  If he had won the contest the folks at "Idol" would have owned him for the next who knows how many years...so the way I see it he's much better off.
586927
2 hours, my achin' butt. Waaay too long. An hour is fine. 2 songs apiece and the usual garbage from the judges. \n\n30 is a bit short. But I'd take 30 over 2 hours. \n\nWho's going to win? We voted for Kat, but it looked like the judges wanted to throw it to Taylor. Kat's single song was not in her range and was eminently forgettable as music. Grrr. (A Kat fan, here, obviously.)
425221
it was already on where i live. MANDISA GOT VOTED OFF!!! and elliot and paris were in the bottome three too... what a sin! ace and bucky are sucky!! but at least they're doing queen music next week so theyll both do bad and get voted off one.
932689
well Simon got rid of Robert last night because he was a theat to Leona where as Eton Road are not going to win if they carry on singing like they did last night,\n but i think that the semi-final will be \nBen for Sharon\nLenoa for Simon\nMcDonald Brothers for Louis \nwhich is 1 act each then i think the final will be Ben & Leona, Sharon is likely to win because Simon won the first year with Steve Brook Stine & Louis Won Last year with Shanye Ward so its Sharons turn to win with Ben, who is her only act now but i think Ben Is the best anyway now out of who is left there now plus im from Whitstable same as Ben so............... \n\nBEN to Win!!!!!!!!!
484558
Well I have lost hope that people will do the right thing when it come to voting...in ANY election, but if there are enough people that recognize talent still out there in America, Katherine will be going home TONIGHT!!!
977343
First of all Elvis will comeback ( 1950's thin.) before Christ. You have a great loaded question.