who is more deserving to be in the final 3 of American Idol 5,Elliott Yamin or Katharine Mcphee?
540926
Elliott Yamin is the one who could benefit most from the exposure as American Idol.  He's the most talented.
660192
my guess would be taylor unless all elliot fans start voting for kat (in that case then she might have a chance)\nhave you visited  officialsoulpatrol.com?  it's a great webiste for taylor fans
500775
I say Taylor because he is different and the ONLY one up there with soul and who feels every song.\n\nBottom 2 next week:  Elliott and Katherine.  Elliott is out. (but I wish Katherine would leave).
1182303
Elliot Yamin\n\nGuys, do me a favor, answer this question for me.\nhttp://answers.yahoo.com/question/index;_ylt=AglqRW1B8d4LnDBVCCTu6eTsy6IX?qid=20060611210206AA5WSZG
526484
Prolly Elliot, I WISH it would be Katherine though...
602556
No way, Taylor is too popular. I love Elliot but I think he will be next. All Paris' votes will likely go to Kat since she is the only woman left. I predict Taylor will be one of the last 2.
1053358
Well, Katherine McPhee wasn't an American Idol (remember, Taylor Hicks won).  Out of Carrie and Kelly, I GREATLY prefer Kelly Clarkson- Kelly sings good music while Carrie sings country garbage.
531710
Yes! Yes! Yes! Katharine Mcphee is the BEST!!Her voice is totally Increadible!!!! I love her lips!!!and her face!!!She soooo gorgeous!!!!I wish she was the AMERICAN IDOL!! YOU ROCK GIRL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!11
615248
Taylor and Elliot are going to be in the finale...Taylor is going to win...hopefully...Soul Patrol...\n~TabbyCat~
247956
my favorite person on american idol is paris. DOn't know the last name.
104959
here is my top five:Ü\nKatharine Mcphee\nParis Bennett\nLisa Tucker\nTaylor Hicks\nAce Young
675584
Either Taylor or Katherine, but I think Katherine is going to win because she's much better than Taylor, althought he is good too!
576414
i KNOW taylor will win american idol.\n\ni WANT taylor to win. why you ask? well...\n\n1. HE ROCKS!\n2. he's different\n3. he is humble, sweet and kind.\n4. he's absolutely adorable!\n5. KATHARINE SUCKS!
169709
Well, I think Paris is awesome..but Elliot is from my town, so I am voting for him. Taylor is fantastic as well.
631891
American Idol's 5th season is now down to it's second to last week and only three finalists are left! On Tuesday, for the first time this season, the finalists will sing three songs each: one of their choice, one chosen by the Judges and one chosen by legendary music producer Clive Davis. Don't miss a note Tuesday, starting at 8/7c. Then, come back Wednesday for a special 1-hour results show, featuring Clive Davis, starting at 9/8c. Only on FOX!\n\nI was SHOCKED also!  I thought the final 2 would come down to Chris & Taylor.  In the hopes of Taylor winning, but Chris is very good also (much better than Elliott or Kat in my opinion.)  Although Im pulling for Taylor I could not believe he was voted off especially befor Elliott!
192471
Katharine, She's consistant and has a wonderfully pure voice.  Truly talented!  She's been my favorite since auditions.  I really think she'll win.
312665
Chris Daughtry, Elliott, Paris, Kellie Pickler, Katharine McPhee, Taylor Hicks