KAT OR TAYLOR?? who do you think will win? why?
536500
SOUL PATROL, SOUL PATROL, SOUL PATROL!!!!\nTaylor Hicks, baby!
615248
Taylor and Elliot are going to be in the finale...Taylor is going to win...hopefully...Soul Patrol...\n~TabbyCat~
577801
I was shocked that the 2 favorites, Kat and Chris were both in the bottom two, let alone that Chris got voted off.  I thought that they were the 2 that best deserved to be in the finals: Chris because he was the best from the beginning and Kat because she had made the most progress, is at least close to Chris in talent now and she has the Idol look and personality.  Chris is more of a rocker and the fans tend to shy away from them a bit.  Chris did have the disadvantage of being one of 3 guys and Kat is the only gal.  Girl fans are so divided between all the guys that it was just a matter of numbers as to the fact a guy would go this week.  I thought it was a poor choice of themes at this stage of the game to have an Elvis theme.  This was Taylor's forte and was very unfair to Kat especially, but also to Chris.  Elliot really stepped up though and he has also improved quite a bit since the beginning of the competition.  Taylor is the novelty factor and I'm shocked he is still there.  I am still hoping for Kat to win, I like her style, her abilities and her personality.
634713
Sorry can't help you and vote for Kat, I am a Taylor fan and will be voting for him..
91934
yeah, imtaken1997 is right. Who will know who's going to win this year's american idol? I think that it's probably going to be Katharine, though I want David or Kellie to win, or meybe even Chris...who knows the future?
595573
elliot! taylor and kat were excellent. he didn't stand up to there level. but that is too bad because i wanted him to win so he could use the money to get braces.
637650
i think Katherine will win....taylor is probably in his 50s and elliot is just down right scary...good vocals but his teeth are all screwed up...freaky! Chris was AWESOME! he didnt deserve to go!
649497
I was so shocked to see him kicked off last night. I really thought it was gonna be Kat. Apparently she did too. Did you see the look on her face? It's okay though cuz he'll get signed before Idol is even over!!!
497869
KAT totally! SHE ROCKS! They both have good voices ubt Taylor ir more of an entertainer type person...kat has so much talent! they both do, but still...she's lots better! and u?
598224
Kat is better lookin than Kelly Clarkson, even tho I dont like Kat lol. That Kellie Pickler was the best looking (except on Queen night), but Lisa Tucker was cute too.
595719
Taylor should be the next American Idol, but the way they are hyping up Kat evrywhere you read. I think America is in for a major let down.
523640
I was thinking Chris or Kelli would win but they are both gone so now I have to say Kat I think she is great and she defiantly looks like a idol!
603365
I don't really like Taylor but I hope he wins over Katharine. She's a boring performer and really seems like a stuck-up bltch sometimes.
468593
Well, let me think.   Wait I don't have to think.  I think the winner will defintely be chris.  i want katherine to win too though.  she has a very unique voice that i have never heard before.  Well all we could do is wait till the season finale.  Can't wait
622117
I totally agree with you. Chris should have won. but between taylor and katherine, i have to say taylor
516322
I voted for Kat to win from the beginning, in fact, with Simon's insensitive comment about Taylor becoming the next AI even before the votes were in, I voted 44 times between my cell and land line....Taylor is an entertainer, but not what I would call an American Idol....Kat will do great, she already has offers for movie roles, and with her good looks, she will be just fine....
667278
I think it might be Elliott....but I really want Kathrine to go home.....I really don't think she's as good as everyone is making her out to be....I would love for Taylor to win the whole thing....he is so awesome!