Who thinks American Idol is going to come down to Katherine and Taylor?
544149
Taylor has stayed true to who he is and what he is good at....great voice,energy,personality....\n\nKatherine....awsome awesome awesome.....an behold, the power of boobs\n\nElliot, no talent no personality HACK
504267
i think its gonna be bye-bye to katherine mcphee. she botched her lyrics, and the dancing was a mess. wrong choice of song to showcase her voice, too. \ni dont watch the model show. sorry.
495136
It was very shocking, however he did not have his best night.  Kat should have been booted, hoever she is too damn FINE!  So the votes went to her hot and sext look instead of Chris.  Elliot and Taylor have their fanbase.  It is a major top 3.  Major.  There is no way to know who will win.  I pick Elliot simply because he is the best singer.  Taylor however is the best performer, and Katherine sings the best for a female this year and I think she may be better than Carrie Underwood from last year.  It will be a thriller.....
398421
so hard to say, it really depends what song choices they make. (seems that way after the last couple weeks)\ni'll take a guess and say paris, elliot and possibly kelly or taylor
675584
Either Taylor or Katherine, but I think Katherine is going to win because she's much better than Taylor, althought he is good too!
608804
This season of American Idol is crazy-- it's hard to tell who will be in the final two now that Chris is gone. Taylor is probably a lock, as much as I care for both Elliott and Katharine; I say probably because anything could happen. \n\nIt really depends. Consistency is a major major issue with both of these, Katharine especially. Performance-wise, Elliott has done nothing but grow in the past couple of weeks. Katharine, however, started off as a favorite to win it all, but now she's slipping for one reason or another.\n\nSpeaking of the fan-base, however, Elliott has a much smaller one. The male demographic will obviously vote for Katharine, and will vote even more depending on how skimpy her dress is Tuesday night. \n\nIt's a tossup right now, but I'd put my money (or yours, rather) on Taylor vs. Elliott in the finals. I believe the whispers among the fans that say that they'll be voting for Elliott and Taylor to avenge Chris' "wrongful departure". But you never know.
672871
Kat should cuz Taylor ain't good at all. And i think it is set up for him to win... don't know why though.
485700
good question for so early of the day\nI think Elliott will go home I personally like him \nbut I think alot of people are judging him by his looks so he will be going home for those reasons  but I so hope I am wrong  I would like Katherine to go because she HAS no personality
452939
Chris will win. the top 3 will be chris, kat and taylor..but hopefully chris will take it
91934
yeah, imtaken1997 is right. Who will know who's going to win this year's american idol? I think that it's probably going to be Katharine, though I want David or Kellie to win, or meybe even Chris...who knows the future?
1112478
Taylor is great He's unique, and totally deserves winning. \n\nKatharine's is ok. Her voice is nice but the music world has too many bubblegum pop female singers. I think Chris Daughtry should have taken Katharine's place in the top 2.
719869
i'm really rooting on Taylor Hicks. I'm sooo happy he got though to the finale, but if Kat wins, i guess she deserves the spotlight just as much as Taylor or any of the contestants do.\n\nVOTE FOR TAYLOR!! \n*jumps up and down*
128625
I do like to watch American Idol, but was a little disappointed with last season.  I thought that Constantine shouldn't have been sent home when he was.  There was no way that Scott Savol was better than him.  Anyway, that was last year.  This year I think it's going to be the guys turn to win... I really like Taylor Hicks and Chris Daughtry and of course Ace.  :)  It would be nice to see Taylor or Chris win; they aren't the "sterotypical" idols the judges and America seem to be looking for.
546564
I like Katherine and Chris and so does my mom, I like Kelly Clarkson the best though. Katherines gonna kick butt!
718516
I think Taylor Hicks is a good singer and a great entertainer but I wish Elliot would have won.  He has the best voice!  Chris is awesome too.  I would have loved to see him win.  I don't like Katherine.  I think she kinda stuck up and full of herself.  \n\nWhat would happen though - if we voted for who should leave A.I. instead of who should stay?  I bet different people would be at the end.
533984
I think Katherine is the best singer, however, I believe Taylor will win.
180244
I want Taylor to win. I think it is between Taylor and Chris. Katherine is great too, but she isn't quite as consistent as Taylor and Chris. Chris could leave the show right now and get a record deal anywhere. I think several of them will become stars after the show because they are really talented. Elliot, Mandesa, Lisa, Chris, Taylor, Paris and Katherine should all become famous, they all have amazing voices.