Where Would Carrie Underwood Be If She Never Tried Out For American I-Dull?
547648
Scooping up cr@p from animals on a farm!
595719
Taylor should be the next American Idol, but the way they are hyping up Kat evrywhere you read. I think America is in for a major let down.
704443
I would defenitily choose Kelly Clarkson for a number of reasons. First every song she released from her debut album went to the number one hit. Secondly she won american idol. And lastly in 2005 she had the #1 hit of the year and I believe if I'm not mistaken also the album of the year.
295289
she has an awsome voice and reminds me alot of carrie (from last year) both are country singers, very down to earth, and extremely likeable. (very important in the competition)  she's not full of her self like alot of the other one's are (including paris)  i think that even if she doesn't win she will still get a recording contract for sure.
536672
Maybe. She doesn't sound that great. I wouldn't buy her album. Good question. :-)
514642
Taylor would be great in concert, BUT no one would buy his CD. I rather buy Kat's CD. \n\n\nP.S. The winner AND the runner-up both get recording contacts. The winner gets the title American Idol.
452476
Nahhhhh\nTaylor hicks all the way\n\n\nKellie is just like Carrie Underwood\n\nand I really don't like country music :(
252387
Yes. I think Carrie is a great singer. She deserved to win.
425688
a pop star with nothing new at all
641671
Toby Keith or Kenny Chesney; Reba McIntire or Martina McBride
128240
I'd have to say Carrie Underwood, cause shes from Oklahoma like me. Like 30 minutes away actually.
456477
Carrie because she has underwood not underwear.
818965
Before he cheats- carrie underwood
456524
Normally I would go with anything other than the Bible, but if you saw Blondie's induction into the Rock & Roll Hall Of Fame then you'll know that Debbie Harryis a self centered, washed up, has-been, who should have been a "never-was". She looks more like a used up soccer mom than a punk rock queen. There, I said it.
568796
as a runner-up from american idol--no way! she would never be accepted into that world!
42468
Kelly Clarkson is by far the most successful.  The least successful American idol I think is probably Fantasia.  Carrie Underwood is at least doing commercials (Hershey) and I think is doing okay in the country genre.  Ruben Studdard had that one relative hit, "Sorry 2004."  But Fantasia hasn't really done anything.
234591
I thought she was ok UNTIL she forgot where she came from and tried to deny american idol to use any of her songs on the show. I think that shows a lot of disrespect for those involved on the show and her fans that helped her win.