why did taylor(AMI) won?
545446
Kat is better by far if the Taylor fans would just watch the earlier shows and really pay attention they will see he should have been gone a long time ago! They must have bad hearing and can't hear how he truly sounds!I do have bad hear and even I can hear he sucked! He should have been one of the first to go out of the first one the judges choose then they went to Hollywood that's when he should have went there where far better ones that didn't get to stay on then him!
544149
Taylor has stayed true to who he is and what he is good at....great voice,energy,personality....\n\nKatherine....awsome awesome awesome.....an behold, the power of boobs\n\nElliot, no talent no personality HACK
503907
ITS RIGGED, if you want to send a message to the producers then don't watch it. I think they have had Cat in position to win for months.  I like Taylor better but honestly Chris should've been the winner.
390556
Taylor is the best i will vote for him he will win it all
301715
If it's a personality test...Taylor hands down. He connects with the people...\n\nChris is seasoned and knows exactly where he is headed.  He is confidant...yet not offended when Simon has a put down waiting for him.  He seems more marketable.\n\nFor all of you who hate this show....leave us alone.  There are thousands of questions to answer???? It's a sign of bad breeding...don't you know?
528381
Katharine is a much better singer than Taylor is, but taylor is a performer, and he works the audience very well.  That's why i think he won.  however, in the long run, katharine will sell more albums.  And oh yeah, neither of them come close to being as good as Carrie Underwood.
560844
i think it was awesome...taylor rocks, literally, kat was good too but someone had to win.
586746
If Chris Daughtry won American Idol he wouldn't have gotten deals because he would have had one already....So as Chris said on the news....Things happen for a reason...he was better off by not winning it.   BUT HE IS THE REAL WINNER!!!
677480
Taylor will win! Because of the entertainment part. But Katherine obviously has a star voice. Taylor will win! Elliots fans will turn to Taylor now. Taylor will win! Oh Yeah! Did I mention Taylor will win!
689291
Despite the judges criticisms and predictions, I thought they both performed equally well. They are both fantastic. I voted for Taylor though because he's infectiously energetic and not afraid to get wrapped up in the heart of the music and dance around and be generally embarassing to himself. Gotta love that. But I would be happy for Kat too.
928545
ME ME ME!!!! emit was stiff and didnt do alot of moving... mario was great .. fantastic... the only reason emit won was cuz he has the damn football fans.... mario was definitley the best and he deserved to win
546739
I hope she wins.  She and Taylor both have great voices, no doubt about that, but she is more of an "idol" type than he is.  He reminds me of a Karaoke singer.
502613
The all kind of won, because the three that didn't win will still be able to pursue their dreams as companies came to back them up.  The 1st place winner was the child seat, he got the million bucks and a deal with baby product company.  The 2nd place winner was the word game, that inventor got a deal with hasbro/parker bros.  Third place was the football gear, that inventor got a deal with Rice ( a famous reciever) to manufacture his product. Fourth place went to the bicycle inventor, who got a deal with Trek bicycle company to make his bike and got a congratulations via sattelite tv with Armstrong (the tour de France winner).  :)
519108
Taylor Taylor Taylor!!
620493
Based on last night's performances, Taylor.
692696
I have been voting for Elliott.  I think he sings better than Taylor, but Taylor obviously has a better personality and in the long run may be a better performer.  Taylor tries to perform for the crowd.
685772
As good as they both were, i think Taylor will be our next American Idol. Katherine is a great performer, but Taylor is an entertainer! I've not seen an entertainer like Taylor since Elvis Presley! With their own unique styles.. Am I the only one who sees a remarkable resemblance in Taylor and Elvis??  That should tell us all how great his potential in show business could be...  I just hope he handles it better than Elvis did in his later years...  Go Taylor...  SOUL PATROL!!!