Do you think Taylor hicks should have won American idol?
553480
It was a tough decision, when it is the final two one of the idol has to win.  Katharine McPhee was a good singer. Everyone felt that Taylor is much more better than Katharine.  America felt that he should be the next American Idol because everyone liked him by his singing and personality.  I felt that Katharine should have deserve the title if she did win.  Since, Katharine is the runner up, she learned that she made it through the competition and she never gives up.  If I was in her shadow either I win or lose, all I care about that I succeed making it to the final.
1021179
I think Elliot Yamin should have won. He's humble and has a great voice. Yeah so he's not HOT like Chris , or crazy like Taylor Hicks, but look at Queen and Kiss they were not the best looking bands in the world but they still rocked.
386747
You spelled it right. Taylor Hicks deserves to win but I'm sure that Chris Daughtry will win...
484143
TAYLOR!  Since day 1 (ok... i changed after paris was voted off... lol)  and he DEFINATELY deserves it!  \n\nChris is gone because he should be!  He was NOT versitile... he sang different songs the same way OVER AND OVER AND OVER AND OVER again... and he claimed that one song I walk the line to be original... and he COPIED it!  He's a total phoney bologna!  LOL!  I do think he's a good guy though, taking that woman and her kid in... thats sooo cool.  He's just a wedding singer though. :)
337923
Hell Yeah she should've have won! i mean have you heard the awesome songs such as Joy Ride and Circles. i thought she got shafted. i think she also should have won Best Tradiontal R and B vocals for Mine Again. but whatever. dont call it a comeback because Mariah's here to stay!
862987
Neither. Chris Daughtry should have won. Stupid voting system.
396890
Chris Daughtry...I've voted for him and Taylor Hicks over this season, because I think they're both more talented than any of the girls. Katharine McPhee is OK, but I think Chris appeals to a broader audience.
615706
Congratulations to Taylor hicks he is our new American idol!!!! i knew he would win!!!! he's good and talented much more so than Katherine!!!! i really wanted Chris but since that couldn't be i am glad its Taylor!!!! the show was awesome with all those guest stars and performances.
233541
Taylor Hicks or Lisa Tucker
643370
I wouldn't say the season has been a waste since we saw a lot of talented singers.  However, if the purpose of American Idol is to find a talented singer,  I think they failed.  Mandissa was the female singer that was the strongest vocally.  For males, hands down Chris and Elliot were the best vocals.  I think Taylor has been successful in entertaining the crowd every week.  Katherine however, has had to stoop to using her appearance and sex appeal to remain in the competition.  Her sultry looks into the camera, low cut and skimpy attire, etc kept her in the competition.  How many times did we hear the judges comment on her appearance instead of her singing?  OUt fo teh remaining contestants..my vote is for Taylor.
477253
Taylor Hicks and Paris Bennett\n\nThough I love Katherine McPhee, I think those two have already won over America.
526514
I personally would have preferred Chris Daughtry to be the American Idol winner, but when it was down to Taylor and Katherine, I have to admit I wanted Taylor to ultimately win!  \n\nHe has charisma and a unique singing style that will help him establish himself in the pop industry. He definitely has his own sound, and you'd know who it is when you hear him singing.
541260
You could say I was pissed off at first. I really thought he would, and deserved, to win. But I think Taylor has a good chance. He has such a great, real personality. I think Chris will do fine in this business, so that's why I'm not pissed anymore :)
514642
Taylor would be great in concert, BUT no one would buy his CD. I rather buy Kat's CD. \n\n\nP.S. The winner AND the runner-up both get recording contacts. The winner gets the title American Idol.
621423
me 2, Kat was soooo awesome.  She totally should have won, i mean her version of "over the rainbow" was mind blowing.  Taylor never should have won, it was probably rigged.
652446
I'm with you. However, I think if Katherine had chosen to sing the way she did on Wednesday night, she could have won it. She has a really beautiful voice when she chooses to sing, yet most of the time she seems to want to sound like Mariah Carey or similar...yuck.\n\nTaylor is far more versatile in what he can sing and still sound great. He can do soft, fast, rock, R&B. This is why he was chosen over Chris, Elliot, or my other faves - Kellie & Bucky.  But, if Bucky or Kellie were to put out some music, I'd buy theirs, too.
719869
i'm really rooting on Taylor Hicks. I'm sooo happy he got though to the finale, but if Kat wins, i guess she deserves the spotlight just as much as Taylor or any of the contestants do.\n\nVOTE FOR TAYLOR!! \n*jumps up and down*