Whothinks Eliot should of won on American Idol?
546786
I think Elliott should have won, but between Kat and Taylor, Taylor was the best. I'm a fan of Taylor, but Elliott has a better voice than Taylor.
560827
I pick Taylor from the minute that I saw his audition.  When Simon told him if his hair was a different color, He would move him to the next round. I honestley didn't think he would go all the way at first, but when he started improving himeself, I new he would. Kat should have been gone a long time ago, Actually my opinion, chris should have been standing up there beside Taylor, But... Go Taylor Go. Soul Patrol
593717
I hope everyone votes for Elliott next week. I don't think it is fair to him. He is an excellent performer. I think people are voting for the others because of the way they look. Anyone who isn't sure, please vote for Elliott. He deserves it. I know I'm going to vote a lot next week.
524127
Taylor Hicks will be the next "American Idol." Taylor has already shown that he is successful. I think that Katherine should have been voted off last week instead of Elliot. Katherine has a lovely voice, but she sings like too many others singers.  Taylors voice is unique and different. If you are not a member of the "Soul Patrol" just watch the American Idol tonight. You will see why he has so many in the "Soul Patrol."
495136
It was very shocking, however he did not have his best night.  Kat should have been booted, hoever she is too damn FINE!  So the votes went to her hot and sext look instead of Chris.  Elliot and Taylor have their fanbase.  It is a major top 3.  Major.  There is no way to know who will win.  I pick Elliot simply because he is the best singer.  Taylor however is the best performer, and Katherine sings the best for a female this year and I think she may be better than Carrie Underwood from last year.  It will be a thriller.....
501924
I think it will be Kat if the phone votes were based on performance and not on her popularity.  She is an awesome talent but wasn't at her best last night.  Elliot is by far NOT my favorite, but I think he did a great job - even the judges thought so.  I think every contestant will get a contract from somewhere.
204683
i think it's gonna be either melissa (just for messing up the lyrics) kevin or bucky.\ni think if i had the choice i'd vote out melissa just because she screwed up the lyrics not once but twice, once while practicing and again on stage.\nthe top 12 needs to be extra careful about not only singing their best but picking the right song and forget about forgetting lyrics!\n("i'm surprised simon didn't lay it into her)
553480
It was a tough decision, when it is the final two one of the idol has to win.  Katharine McPhee was a good singer. Everyone felt that Taylor is much more better than Katharine.  America felt that he should be the next American Idol because everyone liked him by his singing and personality.  I felt that Katharine should have deserve the title if she did win.  Since, Katharine is the runner up, she learned that she made it through the competition and she never gives up.  If I was in her shadow either I win or lose, all I care about that I succeed making it to the final.
523656
In my opinion, I think Katharine should have won. She has talent beyond belief. Chris is also extraordinary, but actually, it's a good thing he didn't win, because he isn't going to be bound by a contract with AI like Taylor is. Chris is an icon of his own, and WILL go far! He honestly didn't even need AI, because his talent speaks for itself! Taylor is good, don't get me wrong, but he's more of a novelty, and would be great in Vegas.
626998
Elliot, about time, I still can't believe that he made it that far in the show ! What was America thinking, to keep him on the show for sooo long...! They got rid of Chris, but kept him !! boooo.....lol
449810
I think that he should be the next American Idol because he's good and at least he's going to bring a different music into the program. Although I prefer pop music but it could be a good change for rock music. Plus, his voice is good too...and his looks! He has the idol look!
580975
i think taylor deserved to win.. not only beacause he has a good voice.. is a weird dancer.. and he was there till the end.. but he seems to be a very down to earth guy, who wont let being in the public eye change the type of person he is.
1131689
either elliot or chris should've won, hands down.
596429
yes i know chris should have won the whole thing but elliot is going tonight  (i found out from dialidol.com)\ni'm sure he'll get a recording contract though, he's got an awsome soulful voice!
659999
your right but whatever is left, i think between those two, Katherine must win...she's at least better than that Taylor person...he is a weirdo...
630925
I can't stand Taylor...I know it.  Anyway, I hope Elliot wins.  I don't care for Katharine, she's boring and forgettable.  Doesn't seem sincere either.
538739
I like Kat.  I thought she and Chris would be in the top two.  It's been hard for the last few weeks, because I like all the contestants at this point. \n\nI think Taylor will do well at whatever he does.  He's already got performing experience.  Kat or Elliot would benefit most from winning in the sense that they could use the polishing, I guess.  Kat would be even more amazing if she had Taylor's confidence and showmanship.  He's got about 10 years on her, though. For her age and experience, I think she's the best - has the most potential.  Also, the best voice.