Joe Namath or Joe Montana? Why?
553826
I'd have to agree with Oldsage. Montana was in a league of his own. Montana will go down as a legend..the skills of Montana were out of this world...the Micheal Jordan of the NFL in my opinion. If Montana were young all over again every team in the league would want him...if Namath were young again he would maybe be a back-up for New Orleans or\nDetroit...he just doesn't have the skills. Namath made his name after Super Bowl 3...more of a celebrity than a gifted athlete as Montana was. Namath had the ONE year with good stats 4000 yards passing with a All-Pro offensive line and a great reciever named Don Maynard...the Jerry Rice of his day!
734981
HAHA fair enough. I would say Rocky, because he carries himself better. He could take a better hit and last longer. And he doesn't have a lisp lol.
249476
To answer this question, you have to ask "How is a QB judged?"  .  If it is by championships, then it is Montana.  If you judge by statistics, then Young is all-time leader in passing efficiency.  If you judge by leadership, it's hard to argue that there was a better motivator/leader than Montana.  If you judge by athleticism, Young's ability to run changed the game forever.\n\nI'm a HUGE Steve Young fan and he is probably my favorite player of all time, but I'd have to give the edge to Montana for this reason:  he was able to take 3 vastly different teams to the Superbowl 4 times.  The 81 Team was so much different than the 85 team, which was different than the 88-89 teams.  There was no Jerry Rice or John Taylor in 85 and no Roger Craig on the 81 squad.  Joe was the constant and to me, that's what makes him extraordinairy. When you look at the Steelers of the 70's, and the Cowboys of the 90's they did it with the same core group.  The 49ers of the 80's were truly led by the game's great all time QB.
777791
I would pick Delhome over Romo.  and Joe Horn over Furrey because anyone that plays for the Lions sucks.
836454
You'll never win this argument, although one could argue that Roy was certainly more important to his team than Elway was.\n\nThe Broncos, likely, would have won with a lesser QB in their Super Bowl wins (now, we're not talking JP Lossman here...maybe Dilfer or McNair)...where as Roy was the one who put the Avs/Nords over the top to win their first drink from Lord Stanley.\n\nBoth players had baggage...Roy's exit from Montreal was ugly...Elway's issues with Dan Reeves almost made him exit Denver.  However, football is a much more popular sport in Denver and, unless you are comparing the likes of Bobby Orr to Tom Brady, no hockey player could ever win this...and even Orr wins only by a hair there.
76811
Bob Harper.  He's better looking and a tougher trainer.
376943
Jim Brown or Walter Payton.
761781
LT, because he is a threat also as a receiver and even occasionally can throw the halfback pass. He is a threat in multiple ways more so than LJ.\n\nThis is not to take away from LJ, who is an outstanding back, one of the NFL's finest.
817597
Ever heard of Joe Montana?  Here is a short list of the best ones I can think of:\n\nJoe Montana\nDave Casper\nTim Brown\nMark Bavaro\nDave Duerson\nSteve Beuerlein\nRick Mirer\nJerome Bettis\nAaron Taylor\nDavid Givens\nTony Fisher\nJulius Jones
419487
Peyton Manning (Now)\nJoe Montana (All Time)
80827
I say Peyton since he has been with the NFL alot longer but there both great players. Payton has been around a long time and never went to a superbowl and Ben is playing in a superbowl today!
172458
Brady, Elway, and Nameth are known more for their Super Bowl victories.\n\nAikman, Young and Montana had SB titles AND great stats, but it is Joe Montana that has more recognition because ha has more Super Bowls than either of the other two, and his statistics are legendary.
46336
Peyton Manning....all by himself!\n\n....Okay....maybe some help :)
964220
I really like the both of them since i'm a freak in X-men and LOTR movies. But if i had to chose a character for snake then i'd definitely chose Hugh Jackman because he's already given us a bad ass, don't really give a shit about consequences character in wolverine. Snake is basically that as well.
812415
Most exciting:  Randall Cunningham\nGreatest winner:  Joe Montana
719080
Jeffy!!!\n\nJeffy is WAY cooler! Way better wrestle, way better looking...\nAnd he's not a whining double standard hypocrite...
962789
Where are the Aikman's. Marino, Elway, Montana, Young. I guess Favre is in there, he was good and kind of still is. I liked Staubach and Unitus too. Too many to list. Nameth. Bradshaw.