So ... who do YOU think will win American Idol 5? Katharine or Taylor?
548651
i want to taylor to win,katherines huge hair scares the living bejesus out of me!i wont get to se it until saturday as im in ireland
667278
I think it might be Elliott....but I really want Kathrine to go home.....I really don't think she's as good as everyone is making her out to be....I would love for Taylor to win the whole thing....he is so awesome!
353977
taylor, katherine, or chris!
1112478
Taylor is great He's unique, and totally deserves winning. \n\nKatharine's is ok. Her voice is nice but the music world has too many bubblegum pop female singers. I think Chris Daughtry should have taken Katharine's place in the top 2.
595719
Taylor should be the next American Idol, but the way they are hyping up Kat evrywhere you read. I think America is in for a major let down.
91934
yeah, imtaken1997 is right. Who will know who's going to win this year's american idol? I think that it's probably going to be Katharine, though I want David or Kellie to win, or meybe even Chris...who knows the future?
615706
Congratulations to Taylor hicks he is our new American idol!!!! i knew he would win!!!! he's good and talented much more so than Katherine!!!! i really wanted Chris but since that couldn't be i am glad its Taylor!!!! the show was awesome with all those guest stars and performances.
468593
Well, let me think.   Wait I don't have to think.  I think the winner will defintely be chris.  i want katherine to win too though.  she has a very unique voice that i have never heard before.  Well all we could do is wait till the season finale.  Can't wait
553480
It was a tough decision, when it is the final two one of the idol has to win.  Katharine McPhee was a good singer. Everyone felt that Taylor is much more better than Katharine.  America felt that he should be the next American Idol because everyone liked him by his singing and personality.  I felt that Katharine should have deserve the title if she did win.  Since, Katharine is the runner up, she learned that she made it through the competition and she never gives up.  If I was in her shadow either I win or lose, all I care about that I succeed making it to the final.
309619
I think Chris should win. He has the talent, passion, and vision to have a great career. Ace will be around a little longer because too many women find him hot! (something I can't see) I'm sad Mandisa got voted off but I understand why...religion and AI don't go together. Paris is too young and is to abnormal for the whole public scene. Taylor is WAY to Taylor to mode into the 'pop idol' form. Katherine...only one I'm not sure about. I think she sings well but she has to have more fire I think. Kelly, Bucky and Elliot...there time is up! Why can't we vote all three at a time.\n\nOh and Bucky's only around because of this site that votes for the worse singers on the show. They pride themsevles on keeping the weak person on to piss others off. Even though they 'say' they picked Kelly to vote for...it seems most of them want to see Bucky around.
602556
No way, Taylor is too popular. I love Elliot but I think he will be next. All Paris' votes will likely go to Kat since she is the only woman left. I predict Taylor will be one of the last 2.
595071
I love the show even though I live in the UK. Chris was my favourite and it was sad to see him voted off. I think that Katherine will win as she has a very strong voice, providing that she chose the right songs. The wrong choice of song could lose her the contest.Taylor seems a nice lad but I think he comes across too much like a partying karaoke singer.
518766
I loved Chris, as most of America did, and thought he was guaranteed the win.  At this point, I really hope Taylor wins.  Katherine is an ok singer most of the time, but she is very inconsistent in her performances.  My friends at the karaoke pub usually do as well as she does, depending on how much they've had to drink:)  However, America is so wrapped up in looks and the "total package" that I think Kat will win because she looks the part.
491774
I'll guess either Paris or Katharine.
501323
Taylor! I want him to win so bad he's cute and sang his butt off. I luv the way he acts the way he talks I luv em.
579554
Taylor, He is so unique. Katherine is like any other singer out there ... w/ amazing talent tho, but the music world needs Taylor.
396890
Chris Daughtry...I've voted for him and Taylor Hicks over this season, because I think they're both more talented than any of the girls. Katharine McPhee is OK, but I think Chris appeals to a broader audience.