Which judge do u like the most in american idol? randy, paula, or simon?why?
453095
Randy: I agree with him MOST of the time\nPaula: LOL!!!! LOL!!! LOL!!!\nSimon: Although he's tough, straight forward, and blunt with them...He's my favorite. I think he trys to motivate them by saying the things that he says, people just take it the wrong way. But that's how I like to communicate with people...just to say how you feel and be honest.
216172
SIMON!!!\nOMgosh he makes the entire show!!!!!!!!!!\n\nhe is the only one who is honest 100% of the time, although randy has been more honest this year than he ever has before\n\nBut Simon is the best because he is freaking hilarious like something crazy!\nIf Simon wasn't on the show, I wouldn't watch it. Amazingly hilarious he is.\n\nPaula is annoiying with "always nice and encouraging reviews"\nand Randy gets on my nerves because he says "dog" too freaking much! How annoying is that? "HIs dog pound"--oh please! get real, that sounds so freaking ridiculous, how can anybody stand that? He is so cheesy. At least Simon is perfect on the show.
332431
Definitely Ashley. Melina is cool but she`s such a brat!!! I mean come on,always cheating to help MNM on WWE!!!! I don`t know Ashely but anybody is better than Melina.(Ashely must be new right?)
229123
I love it and never miss a show! I like to hear the people auditioning better than the people who sing with music. I mostly watch it because Simon is so mean and its funny, but he went a little overboard this year whe he said they needed a bigger stage. Also, my brothers friend is named Taylor Hicks! When we heard his name my brother nearly jumped out of his skin, and ran to call his friend. It was soooooooo funny!
417499
My top 3 faves are McPhee, Pickler and Chris -- it's tough to predict the actual winner.  I think if McPhee can build a bigger fan base, she could have a good shot.  I think both Pickler and Chris are very one sided -- they only know how to sing one type of music -- they haven't shown much diversity.  McPhee's got the look and the talent.  It's obvious the judges like her and I think she's growing on America.  They're making her out to be a very American girl with an ideal family upbringing - very positive spin.  I think Pickler's naivety is going to start to bug people - it's cute, but only for so long.  I like Chris, but like I said, he only sings rock songs.
378381
I missed Katherine and Elliott, But Kellie was horrible and the judges really give it to her..Chris had the best performance and Taylor was second, in my opinion.
250388
While he comes across as a jerk MOST OF THE TIME, he is also Correct MOST OF THE TIME.\n\nHe could & should break it to these performers is a nicer way than he normally does, but he is a good critic if you ask me which is what this competition needs. Paula Abduffus always thinks everybody is wonderful and never says a negative word unless Randy has spoke up before her...\n\nSeems like Simon is getting nicer though in recent weeks...
933961
Miss J Alexander who is the really funny judge on America's Next Top Model is dating Jay Manuel. I think thats really funny that there dating, I love both of them! My favorite show is America's Next Top Model!
287777
I totally agree with browneyedmaiden on the more-than-one american idol thing...but I have to say Chris Daughtry has the most chances of winning...but I'm still rooting for David to stay on the show tonight! :P
89251
I love Monica. Her obsession with everything being clean is always funny.  I also love Rachel.  She always seems like the mature one.  Then there's Chandler, always ready with a joke whether it be bad or good.  And Ross the serious one who doesn't exactly have a way with the ladies. Finally Joey because...he's Joey.  I love them all and Friends is my favorite show.
1091233
I like the two brothers on the show supernatural. They're hott! The hottest couple would have to be ross and rachel!
393370
The answer is in the question. It is American Idol.  Why would they ever continue to choose a black to represent America?  They gave us Rubin and Fantasia why do we feel they will give us any other black.  The show is not about who can sing the best it is about ratings.  Look at the judges and you'll have what the show is all about. Paula (has been), Randy (who knew him prior) and Simon (famous from the show). Watch for fun not for reality.
944665
Ryan Seacrest\nKatie Couric\nDiane Sawyer\nImus\nThe judges on "Dancing with the Stars".\nThat he/she/it thing (judge), on "America's Next Top Model".\nThat has-been Janice somebody with the screeching voice that used to be on it.\nAlex Trebeck\nConan
343861
I thought Katherine, Taylor, and Chris had the best performances. The rest sucked. I think Randy is on crack, Paula needs to get real, and Simon well sometimes he is honest but I don't always agree with him.
128625
I do like to watch American Idol, but was a little disappointed with last season.  I thought that Constantine shouldn't have been sent home when he was.  There was no way that Scott Savol was better than him.  Anyway, that was last year.  This year I think it's going to be the guys turn to win... I really like Taylor Hicks and Chris Daughtry and of course Ace.  :)  It would be nice to see Taylor or Chris win; they aren't the "sterotypical" idols the judges and America seem to be looking for.
958418
Yes!  I love Simon...Paula doesn't even make sense most of the time
688274
I LIKE RANDY ORTON. HE IS SEXY AND HE IS A GOOD WRESTLER. PPL HATE ON HIM CAUSE HE IS COCKY BUT THAT MAKES HIM MORE SEXY. AND I AGREE BESIES BATISTA. HE IS SEXY. RANDY ORTON IS NOT ONLY A LEGEND KILLER BUT A LADYS MAN