Is anyone happy that Kellie Pickler is gone from idol?
450983
I flew from my chair in song and dance.  My ears will finally stop bleeding on Tuesday nights....
504267
i think its gonna be bye-bye to katherine mcphee. she botched her lyrics, and the dancing was a mess. wrong choice of song to showcase her voice, too. \ni dont watch the model show. sorry.
767728
I am very dissaponted.. I really fell for the "normal little country girl" image that she portrayed-- how self-centered can someone be? I'm VERY happy for Carrie Underwood. Faith should have been too--- I mean, she's already got like a million awards- let someone else shine for once!
324350
Tonight we said goodbye to Kellie Pickler.  It was a bit different tonight, as they divided it up into top 2, middle 2, and bottom 2.  Chris and Katharine were the top 2, Kellie and Paris were the bottom 2.
291319
Incredibly happy!  And I can't believe she thinks she is going to make tons of money with an album now.  She had the lowest number of votes even before they get to the Final 12.  I was SO hoping she would get kicked off after her cocky comment last night to Simon that it's a good thing America decides and not him.  I had accurately predicted it would be Brenna and Heather to leave tonight.
323610
He was in the bottom 3 so many times I can't believe it took so long for him to finally be gone. Now its time for Elliott and Katherine to follow. After that, it will be a close race.
300405
Ace...and I'm glad!\nBummed that Paris was in the bottom 3 though...she's got a good voice!
636481
I am shocked and upset to see Chris go, but in the long run I think it will be better for Chris. When you win Idol, you are pretty much put in a prison camp where you are forced to become something you don't want to be, and your are contracted to stay that way for I don't know how long. Ask Kelly Clarkson. Anyway, Chris has become more famous now because of the outrage, and I'd put money on the fact that we will see him again and he will be successful in HIS genre of music. ROCK ON CHRIS!!!!!
375480
if my favorite,Chris gets voted off my next favorite would defintaly Kellie. Is awsome too!!!!!
417499
My top 3 faves are McPhee, Pickler and Chris -- it's tough to predict the actual winner.  I think if McPhee can build a bigger fan base, she could have a good shot.  I think both Pickler and Chris are very one sided -- they only know how to sing one type of music -- they haven't shown much diversity.  McPhee's got the look and the talent.  It's obvious the judges like her and I think she's growing on America.  They're making her out to be a very American girl with an ideal family upbringing - very positive spin.  I think Pickler's naivety is going to start to bug people - it's cute, but only for so long.  I like Chris, but like I said, he only sings rock songs.
615036
I think paris will be kicked off and I will stop watching if Elliot is kicked off. For the sake of getting and " orginal new fresh face" American Idol Katharine needs to go..she is typical of what's currently in the market and her performances have been  getting worse not better.
853604
Hopefully, she wont make anymore albums.  The girl cant sing.  But I do think that her hubby and her decision over the past 2 years have made her out to look like "Trailer Park Trash" so as far as her image goes I think its gonna be good for her.
293471
I'm sorry for you.  That's how I felt when Patrick left.  I really liked Patrick and thought he was such a talented musician. \n\nThe problem I had with David was that I know he can sing, but it didn't seem like he took it as serious as some of the other guys.  I definitely thought he was better than at least 4 others who are still there.  \n\nSo now its time to pick another favorite and cheer them on.  Pick an underdog like Kevin or Will.  I think they are next to go next week.  \n\nI'm voting for Kevin.  He's soooooooooooo cute.  I adore him.
548043
that was Clay? OH OK! I was confused who that was, but happy for the kid to sing that song with Clay. I loved the show. I liked it when Dionne Warwich appeared. I like to see the people voted off perform. I like Elliot and of course I like Chris, but it was nice to see the ones from several weeks ago.
392861
Kelli was sweet but she couldn't sing as well as the remaining contestants.  Sadly, her last song was terrible.  But I like her spirit and her spunk.  I was impressed when she said she's finally reached a point in her life where she's not ashamed of where she came from.  I believe her being on AI will launch her into a life she never imagined.  Contestants don't need to win AI to make big changes in their lives.\n\nEdited to add:  I was afraid Kelli was going to be another Carrie Underwood--AI forcing another dumb blonde on us.  Thankfully, AI gave us a break from the pretty dumb blonde contestants this year and let Kelli go early!
609205
ME!!!!! I was devastated when he got kicked off idol. I am so glad that he got to release an album. I love it & i play it everyday. YaY Lee
415466
I love Chris Kat and Pickler. Taylor I knew from the start that he would go far. I think he is going to make it to the final 3 or 4, not win. Chris and Kat are just too good and liked by too many people.