what do you think abou Kellie Pickler getting voted off American Idol?
447713
She was not at her best. It was fair to me.
853604
Hopefully, she wont make anymore albums.  The girl cant sing.  But I do think that her hubby and her decision over the past 2 years have made her out to look like "Trailer Park Trash" so as far as her image goes I think its gonna be good for her.
229908
---mcphee is good (why are we all refering to her as mcphee now?) but i don't think she has showed enough enthusiasm when she performs to develope a steady fan base. also, she needs a new stylist. her choice of clothing is always appaling. \n---bucky has not a chance except for a miracle. after all, there are only so many people on votefortheworst.com. \n---ace is also a very long long shot. he got too wrapped up in himself and forgot this is a singing competition and not a modeling competition.\n---chris has a lot of talent, but he doesnt' really show much versatiliy, like simon said. maybe he will show us something different with country week... but he does have a strong fanbase and he is talented...\n---kellie pickler is good but i think she relies more on her cute southern girl more than her vocals to carry her through... i don't know if that will be enough tto get her all the way...\n---paris is good, but when you look at all the other talent i don't think she is the best, but they have been showcaseing her from the beginning so she has a bigger fan base than some people.\n---elliot can sing, he is a good performer most of the time, but i don't know if that many people really remember him. i don't think he has a solid shot at winning but he should get pretty far.\n---taylor has a great voice, a unique style, and a unique personality, which makes for a great contestant on american idol... i don't know if he really WANTS to be the next american idol, though, because then they will try and force him into becoming some poppy kelly clarkson thing...\n---mandisa is very talented singer, has a very pretty face, and she has a vrey likeable personality. i think she has a very good chance at winning. \nso, all things considered, it will be mandisa, chris, and taylor in the top three... don't know which one will win though... only time will tell.
660283
It was definitely a shocker for me. I figured he would win. He definitely was the most talented of all contestants. He will be around though so show your support and make sure you follow him on his journey to greatness.\n\nCHRIS DAUGHTRY ROCKS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
718516
I think Taylor Hicks is a good singer and a great entertainer but I wish Elliot would have won.  He has the best voice!  Chris is awesome too.  I would have loved to see him win.  I don't like Katherine.  I think she kinda stuck up and full of herself.  \n\nWhat would happen though - if we voted for who should leave A.I. instead of who should stay?  I bet different people would be at the end.
605548
I HONESTLY THINK THAT THIS SHOW, JUST MIGHT BE RIGGED! Because last nights show...Kathrine was the one that was supposed to go, but right at the last minute, the announcer was told to pick CHRIS. It was so very obvious. How "CRUEL"and How very "HOUND-DOG-GISH"! Wouldn't you all agree? I am very "MAD" about how they tricked CHRIS. He is very, very, very good! And he did not deserve that at all. "BOO.....AMERICAN IDOL"!!!! BY THE WAY, ELLIOTT? well what can I say....YOU ARE! ALWAYS HAVE BEEN! AND WILL BE ....THE NEXT AMERICA'S FANTASTIC, GLORIOUS VOICE, "GOD" LOVING IDOL...AMEN!!! AND MAY GOD BLESS AND BE WITH EACH AND EVERYONE ONE OF YOU!  GOOD LUCK!
617287
I totally agree with you. Chris was the only one left with outstanding vocal ability. Based on her poor selection of songs and her botching up those she did choose, she should have been the one to go last nigh.\n\nHowever, as Seacrest says, "America voted, and....." Chris was voted off.
455934
I think Kellie...or at least I hope so....She's a sweet girl but the 'stupid' act is getting soooo annoying!  That and it's just time for her to go.
324592
chris should win...paris should be gone.bucky, kelly(or kellie)and mandissa should all be back..and i'm so glad ace is gone!he was terrible
524725
do you even watch american idol? what do you mean "who won", Paris got voted off, so Elliot, Kat, Taylor, and Chris would be the "winners".
322738
She sang a horrible song choice (Any Man of Mine by Shania Twain) and even with her voice being good, it didn't sound too good!  Then she made some comments about gays that week and I do believe that dropped a good number of calls for her.  I understand standing up for something you believe in, but can't you wait until after you're voted off or win?????
719546
Personally I thought Kelly Pickler was going to win but she got voted off. So now I think it will either be Chris Daughtery or Katherine McGee. I don't know how to spell her lats name sorry.
372764
Kellie was voted off tonight and even though I am one of her fans I believe it was time for her to go she even said herself that she felt she would be going home tonight. Kellie and Paris where in the bottom two. Elliott and Tatlor where next and Katherine and Chris got the most votes this week.
437543
I might have to agree with you...Elliot or maybe Paris.  But i think it will be Elliot, Paris, and Kellie in the Bottom Three this week.
555309
CHRIS ROCKS!!!! I HOPE HE WINS!!!!!!!!! I REALLY WANT HIM TO WIN, REALLY BAD!!!!!\n\nNobody left tonight yet. I hope Taylor or Elliott goes. But it'll probably be Katharine.\n\nREMEMBER EVERYBODY READING THIS: VOTE FOR CHRIS AT LEAST ONCE!!! PLEASE!!!
471886
This is such a simple, yet complex, question.  Performance-wise, Kellie was the worst on Tuesday night.  It wasn't a bad performance, but it just did not compare favorably to the rest, especially Elliot and Chris.  Thus, she was the most deserving of elimination, if the show was truly only about talent.\n\nHowever, I really, really like Kellie's personality, and I think the show will be the worse for her absence.  She is bubbly, fresh, and unpretentious.  She has the complete package for a star -- looks, talent, drive, and if she isn't the brightest crayon in the box, she certainly has the charm and charisma to play it up.  Despite her elimination, I think America will still hear about what she's up to a year from now and beyond (versus someone like Elliot, who has the talent, but whose personality fades into the background).  She maybe be gone for now, but it's only temporary, and she will definitely never be forgotten.\n\nThis season, for me, has been the most interesting.  At this point last year, I could already tell you when each contestant would be eliminated because it was clear that Carrie and Bo were the most talented.  Vonzell had plenty of talent, but not the fanbases the other two had.  I'm still not quite sure how Anthony and Scott stuck around as long as they did.  Anyway, point being this: it was clear, after Constantine's elimination, who was going to be in the finale.\n\nRight now, I can't say who will win, let alone be in the finals.   They are ALL incredibly talented and unique.  Taylor is souful and spastic.  Chris is smoldering, yet sensitive.  Paris is a little girl with a huge voice.  Katharine is glamorous, with a hint of the girl-next-door.  And even Elliot is emerging as the dark horse favorite.\n\nMore than anything else now, I think the performances are what's going to matter.  Kellie's exit proves that.  She was initially a front-runner for the finals - or at least, to be the last female standing.  However, two shaky performances in a row, and now she's going home.  Taylor, so far, has not wound up in the bottom three, but neither had Kellie before last night.  Chris was the second lowest vote-getter last week, but jumped to the top two for this week.  Kat, Elliot, and Paris have also all been in the bottom 3.  I don't think the race has been this hard to call this far into it since season 2, and then it was really only between two contestants (Rueben and Clay), not five.  \n\nIf I had to say how it would play out (and assuming from here on out every contestant gave stellar performances every week), I would say they rest would be eliminated in the following order:  Paris, Elliot, Chris, leaving Kat and Taylor in the finals, with Kat emerging as the winner.\n\nHowever, one bad or mediocre performance from any of them will change that.  On the flip side, should someone have a truly amazing performance (like Constantine's Bohemian Rhapsody), it will change as well.  In a contest of such strong personalities, it will boil down to performance.\n\n(As for personal favorites, I like Chris!!!)
524127
Taylor Hicks will be the next "American Idol." Taylor has already shown that he is successful. I think that Katherine should have been voted off last week instead of Elliot. Katherine has a lovely voice, but she sings like too many others singers.  Taylors voice is unique and different. If you are not a member of the "Soul Patrol" just watch the American Idol tonight. You will see why he has so many in the "Soul Patrol."