Who is better in American Idol?
90388
Definitely Simon!  If it wasn't for him, I think the show would go downhill very fast.   He keeps things interesting and spices it up.  Randy is just boring, and Paula is too sickenly sweet.  SIMON ALL THE WAY...BAYBEEEE!!
611463
I agree with you all the way!! He does not have charisma as all. I am really shocked that he is still there and Chris is gone.. Chris should have been the American Idol with Taylor coming in second.. Now I hope that Taylor wins...\nLisa
229908
---mcphee is good (why are we all refering to her as mcphee now?) but i don't think she has showed enough enthusiasm when she performs to develope a steady fan base. also, she needs a new stylist. her choice of clothing is always appaling. \n---bucky has not a chance except for a miracle. after all, there are only so many people on votefortheworst.com. \n---ace is also a very long long shot. he got too wrapped up in himself and forgot this is a singing competition and not a modeling competition.\n---chris has a lot of talent, but he doesnt' really show much versatiliy, like simon said. maybe he will show us something different with country week... but he does have a strong fanbase and he is talented...\n---kellie pickler is good but i think she relies more on her cute southern girl more than her vocals to carry her through... i don't know if that will be enough tto get her all the way...\n---paris is good, but when you look at all the other talent i don't think she is the best, but they have been showcaseing her from the beginning so she has a bigger fan base than some people.\n---elliot can sing, he is a good performer most of the time, but i don't know if that many people really remember him. i don't think he has a solid shot at winning but he should get pretty far.\n---taylor has a great voice, a unique style, and a unique personality, which makes for a great contestant on american idol... i don't know if he really WANTS to be the next american idol, though, because then they will try and force him into becoming some poppy kelly clarkson thing...\n---mandisa is very talented singer, has a very pretty face, and she has a vrey likeable personality. i think she has a very good chance at winning. \nso, all things considered, it will be mandisa, chris, and taylor in the top three... don't know which one will win though... only time will tell.
426893
Kellie Pickler and Paris. Kellie because her dumb southern blonde act cannot take her  to the finals and Paris because Taylor, Chris and Elliot are just way better than her in singing abilities. GO Taylor, vote for the silver fox.
500775
I say Taylor because he is different and the ONLY one up there with soul and who feels every song.\n\nBottom 2 next week:  Elliott and Katherine.  Elliott is out. (but I wish Katherine would leave).
524127
Taylor Hicks will be the next "American Idol." Taylor has already shown that he is successful. I think that Katherine should have been voted off last week instead of Elliot. Katherine has a lovely voice, but she sings like too many others singers.  Taylors voice is unique and different. If you are not a member of the "Soul Patrol" just watch the American Idol tonight. You will see why he has so many in the "Soul Patrol."
219954
Here's my top three for American Idol this year:\n1)Elliott because he can sing well and yet he is just homely enough to get sympathy votes and make us feel good that we could advance his career and be the ones to discover his talent.\n2)Katherine because she is talented and beautiful and last night's being in the bottom three will surely humble her from being too prideful.\n3)Mandisa because she already had a career before she became a contestant.  She can sing with great power and is a beautiful role model.\n\nBucky and Kellie can only sing one way and they are not that good.  Randy will always be saying to them, "Dude for me that was just ariiight."  \n\nPaula loves to stand and dance any time she can.  She has the hots for Ace but tries to be encouraging to everyone who can entertain, like Taylor.
553480
It was a tough decision, when it is the final two one of the idol has to win.  Katharine McPhee was a good singer. Everyone felt that Taylor is much more better than Katharine.  America felt that he should be the next American Idol because everyone liked him by his singing and personality.  I felt that Katharine should have deserve the title if she did win.  Since, Katharine is the runner up, she learned that she made it through the competition and she never gives up.  If I was in her shadow either I win or lose, all I care about that I succeed making it to the final.
440205
No, American Idol is too intellectually challenging for him.  He might end up looking stupid.  Oh wait...
348502
I think it will be either her or Chris. I am leaning towards Chris because I like a little hard rock. But she is very beautiful and has a really good voice, and she seems to be improving all the time. I also like Taylor, but he would be third for me.
522072
My thoughts were exactly like yours.  Elliot has been my fave since the 1st time I heard him sing.  He's got such a sexy voice!  It reminds me of Marc Broussard and Donny Hathaway (his idol).  My favorite to win was always Chris though.  I figured since Bo came in 2nd last year, it was time for a rocker to win.  I was happily shocked when he got the boot. \nWhen I saw that Elliot was on Taylor's side, I knew he was safe (Taylor's never in the bottom).  I assumed Katharine would be going, but I wanted Chris to go b/c I figured that would give Elliot a much better chance of winning with Chris outa the picture.  I couldn't believe he left!!\n\nAs nerdy as this is, I had my own "vote-a-thon" for Elliot (30 times through) this week.  Next week I'll be doing even more.  How cool would it be if he actually one?
531710
Yes! Yes! Yes! Katharine Mcphee is the BEST!!Her voice is totally Increadible!!!! I love her lips!!!and her face!!!She soooo gorgeous!!!!I wish she was the AMERICAN IDOL!! YOU ROCK GIRL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!11
546786
I think Elliott should have won, but between Kat and Taylor, Taylor was the best. I'm a fan of Taylor, but Elliott has a better voice than Taylor.
501715
Taylor...His voice is incredible!  He has so much energy & is fun to watch perform.\n\nSoul Patrol!!!
491633
Soul Patrol all the way! I was hoping for a two boy final but sadly Elliot is gone.Really Katherine should have gone before Chris or Elliot!
413241
What I think will be good about this week and the "American Songbook" is that it should showcase the good voices and make the mediocre voices obvious.  I think Katherine would do very well with "Someone to Watch Over Me", Taylor could try "What a Wonderful World" or "As Time Goes By".  I am a bit nervous for Chris, but he did very well with his country song, so hopefully he will come through again. I think that Kellie may have a hard time, but she did very well with Queen, so who knows? Elliot should be in his element this week, so I expect him to do well.  He could do "The Way You Look Tonight" or "I Only Have Eyes for You".  Paris will also probably be fine, this seems like a type of music that will suit her.
528381
Katharine is a much better singer than Taylor is, but taylor is a performer, and he works the audience very well.  That's why i think he won.  however, in the long run, katharine will sell more albums.  And oh yeah, neither of them come close to being as good as Carrie Underwood.