Is Jay Cutler overrated?
90226
He was a little dissapointing in the senior bowl. But he has all the physical tools. Reminds me a lot of Kyle Boller before he was drafted. So yes he is.
825394
I think he's a mirage.  As soon as you hit him one good time he is done.\n\nFor more on the Bears and the NFL, check this site out.  http://factipedia.com/sportsblogs/
251045
Vick, McNabb, Culpepper, Brees and McNair have no right to be lumped with Brady, Favre and Manning. \n\nThe EASY answer is Manning, hands down.\n\nVick is seriously over rated as a QB. He cannot stay healthy and will NEVER be a top QB. He should move to flanker now.\n\nBrees has had two good years and is a good QB. \n\nCulpepper showed what he was made of last year.\n\nMcNair is a warrior who is a very good QB but not worthy of consideration here and not even when he WAS in his prime.\n\nFavre, one of the GREAT ones whose time has passed.\n\nMcNabb - no thanks\n\nBrady - Just Win Baby - a true leader but still a notch below Manning\n\nBetter than some of the ones you listed: Palmer (as stated above) and Hasselbeck are the future of the NFL.
936659
Overrated:  The entire Colts team\nUnderrated: Brian Urlacher and the entire 06 Bears
970411
I think he used to be overrated, especially by those who didn't really follow football too closely, but with the season he is putting up this year, you have to put him at the top of the league corner wise.
1009113
People like to throw out completion rating and TD stats when talking about the Greatest QB ever. The dude is the master of game management.  All that matters is The ring and he has three of them and should be in the top 5.  Just ask Peyton Manning or Dan Marino if he would trade all those stats for a ring.
956385
Notre Dame is overrated.  Everyone thinks because they have Charlie Weiss and Brady Quinn its the next Bellicheck and Brady.  They are not as good as every so called "expert" thinks they are.  Even with John Booty throwing interceptions they couldnt touch USC.. they lost 2 games this season and almost lost to Michigan State but got lucky at the end... maybe with this loss Weiss will quit whining about deserving to be in the national title game
731817
It seems to me that the entire team has been slightly demoralized by their loss to the Colts and Plummer's poor play of late. When Cutler starts I think there will be a definite change in attitude. Some say that Plummer has been affected by the team's treatment of  Cutler in practice. They ooh and ahh over his passes and such, so I can somewhat understand how he feels, but the  fact of the matter is: this is a game and if you can't take the team to where it needs to be, you will be benched.  Look for Cutler and his awesome arm to breathe new life into the team.
555910
He's good but I think he's really overrated. He wasn't even able to lead his team to the second round.
1093245
Overrated - Chicago Bears\nUnderated - Chicago Bears\nBiggest Surprise at Season end - Chicago Bears.
515454
No, Shortdog. He played for Chicago, Portland and Houston before he crapped out completely.  One of the most overrated players in NBA history next to Charles Barkley.
958590
He's the not the best because of the same reasons why Timmy Chang was not the best college QB.  June Jones runs an offense based on run and shoot that favors the passing game.   Then theres the factor that he plays in Western Athletic Conference.  It's not a completely terrible conference but the level of competition is no where near that of the Major Conferences like the Big Ten and SEC).  Poor competition plus pass friendly system equals the opportunity for stat padding.   Stat Padders shouldn't be recognized as the best unless they play the best.
391170
Whatever it is it is probably overrated just like the player. I would rather have David Eckstein for a shortstop.
1091626
I think that it's too early to call him overrated much less underrated. When a star, any star player is given the torch to be the next great one, people should give them 2-3 years to prove it.  A good example is Eric Lindros. Before he even stepped on the NHL ice, he was christened the next great one. Lindros, if not injured flashed signs of brilliance but we'll never really know because of the concussions. I think Crosby matured a lot in his first year and looks to be a stud. But give him some time before we truly rate him.
510464
Yes they are overrated.
376498
Peyton has a great passing game but his running game needs much work.  Thats why we lost E.James.  Also, it seems to me that once he gets flustered, he can't bounce back.\n\nFor the previously answered question, what does the Colts defense have to do with the Peyton Manning being overrated?
878799
LOL, Joey Harrington is on Miami. Maybe u should be in last place. Jay Cutler won't get the start. TRUST ME! So you are stuck with Joey Harrington, who isn't a shabby QB.