is vince young better than matt leinart, i think so?
80706
I think Leinart reads a defense better than Young, but Young has more (by far) athleticism and God given talent.
1168066
Vince Young is great and I think he'll make a splash his rookie year, but more often than not Quarterbacks aren't rushed into the limelight in their first year. A QB is one of your most heavily protected investments in the NFL, and someone like Vince Young or Michael Vick who scrambles a lot will be treated very carefully in his first years to ensure he doesn't get hurt.\nAs much as I hate to say it, because I'm anything but a USC fan, I have to guess it'll be Reggie Bush. He's such a dynamic gamebreaker, and even if he doesn't see a lot of immediate touches at HB he can step in as a WR or return man and show his ability there.\nObviously whoever it is, it will depend on how much playing time they see, how closely protected they are (as many ROTY prospects are often considered a key part, if not the whole, of the franchise's future plans), and whether or not they can stay healthy.
67761
the real question is how good is Young? If you think he was as great as everyone is making him out to be than Texas might as well forfeit all there games. But realistically Young was a great player but not as good as everyone is making him out to be. The rest of the Texas team is what made Young so good, all the need is a good QB and Texas wont miss a beat
891635
My bet on Vince...more entertaining..
898982
I'd go with Leinart. I think that since Young and Harrington are comming off big wins. That they won't perform as well during this week. I'd go with Leinart. Good Luck!
798817
I am not of the school that thinks Reggie Bush won't still be a star.  I do.  I think his receiving game and his speed can still make him a top notch running back.  You can't make the statement that juking doesn't work in the NFL.  Barry Sanders made a career of it.  But when you compare Bush's hype to Vince Young's I think it is unfair.  The experts expected far more out of Reggie Bush in year 1 than Vince Young.  I don't think anyone expected Young to be starting in his 1st year.  I also can't jump on the "Vince Young is great" bandwagon.  He basically had one good game.  I think he has to share praise with Travis Henry for the improvement in the run game.  But to answer your question, I think Vince Young has exceeded his expectations and Bush has fallen short.  Even though Bush's expectations were astronomical.
303350
Matt Leinart for sure. He is the best quarterback in the draft without a doubt. I believe he is NFL ready. USC has run the majority of their formations just like the NFL does.\n\nWhereas Young has been running all his plays in the shotgun. Running all the time can be dangerous in the NFL because of how injury prone you become. \n\nLeinart should be the 2nd person drafted after first draft pick Reggie Bush.
850055
Grossman is going to get eaten alive by New England. If you check Vince Young has been doing very well lately and the last time I looked NYG DEF wasnt on the top of their game the last few weeks. Take a chance on Young you wont be dissapointed.\n\nGood Luck \nHope it helps.
26834
which ever one i could draft...like the titans are gonna do...hehe   but if i have to pick 1 its vince he doesnt have to best WRs or oline in the country like usc does...but he still had 2700..lienart had 3300 ...i think if vince had stayed he would have hit 4000 passing yards and 1500 rushing ....hmmmm just like mcnair did
21335
Vince Young. Best QB legs in the NCAA.
1186547
That's tough. I like Jim McMahon and Steve Young. They were both good in College and won Super Bowls in the NFL. I guess since Young is in the Hall of Fame, that would give him the leg up. Ty Detmer put up great numbers at BYU, but did nothing in the NFL. My heart says McMahon. My brain says Young.
802009
No...it's Matt Leinart...today!
11771
Reggie Bush.   Unless Houston goes for a Quarter Back.  Then It would be Lienart.  Vince Young is not coming out this year he will be a Longhorn next year.  HOOK EM HORNS!!!!!
445832
Vince Young rocks. He is the best player in the draft and desrved to win the Heisman. He's gonna lead Tennessee to the Superbowl in a few years just like he led the Longhorns to the Rose Bowl.
460647
There is an absolute yes matt lienart will probably be drafted by the titans and vince young by the raiders
347650
Warren Moon was 10 times better than both of them....but I would say McNabb is the better QB, although I think Vick is probably more athletic.
741258
I AGREE WITH YOU,BABY. I'VE ALWAYS LIKE HEYMAN HE'S MORE ENTERTAINING TO ME THAN VINCE .AND ECW WOULD BE MUCH MORE ENJOYABLE WITH HEYMAN RUNNING THE SHOW!\n\n(too much mcmahon is not a "good"thing!)