Who's the better qb: Daunte Culpepper or Peyton Manning?
97349
2 time MVP Peyton Manning.
931032
My favorite qb is donovan but i think the best SO FAR is Peyton Manning
772070
LMAO...the very first person to answer felt compelled to bring up Brady's 3 SB rings!  OMG....why do Pats fans use ttht as some kind of symbol of greatness?  TRENT DILFER AND DOUG WILLIAMS!  NUFF SAID!\n\nTo answer your question though...Brees is the better QB this season.
784303
Payton Manning will at the end of his career be the best quarterback to have ever played the game and that will ever play the gave period ... no-one will ever be as good as him ... and the colts will go undefeated this year and win the superbowl easy ... they just got past 2 games inwhich ALL the critics thought they would lose.
784218
Peyton has the better stats so far.  In the long run, much will depend on the teams they are surrounded by.
883804
I'd say Romo because he is playing against the Cardinals defense.  That defense made even Andrew Walter look good.  Plus, Rivers is going to be playing against the Cincinnati defense, which has a strong defensive backfield.  And he won't be passing a lot anyway because of LT being on his team.  Romo's the one to start, he will probably have 30 to 40 passing attempts.
741599
Peyton is the best QB right now definitely. He is a great QB. People always want to include team success with individual attributes. Terry Bradshaw was a decent QB that happened to be on some great teams. Winning Super Bowls doesn't make you a great QB. Look at Big Ben, how great is he? Trent Dilfer? Brad Johnson? Mark Ripien?
68377
Man, that's good and tough question.  I will have to give more than 1 but no more than 2.  Currently, Peyton Manning is the man.  He has character and values that keep him down to earth, unlike TO & Moss.  Also he got shafted with the heisman.  When he is done all NFL quarteback records maybe broken.  ALL TIME - I'd have to go with Barry Sanders.  He was not outspoken, never got into trouble, and always looked like he was having fun.  Not to mention that he was the best running back watch.
1089699
Peyton Manning of the Indianapolis Colts broke Dan Marino's single-season touchdown pass record by completing his 48th and 49th touchdown passes of the season against San Diego in Indianapolis.
863250
Ah, No.  I can think of 5 just off the top of my head who are better.\n1. Joe Montana\n2. Johnny Unitas\n3. Bart Starr\n4. Troy Aikman/Steve Young\n5. John Elway/Dan Marino
944114
Manning, because for one he's a great QB and two he can read defenses.  Plus, he's great leader and you can count on him in tight spots.
1183143
great question..all i can say is that peyton's team is closer...so i'll give the edge to him..
839818
ladanian tomlinson, for QB peyton manning.
726993
Hard to go against Peyton, but Brees against the Bengals I would have to go with Brees. The Cincy-N.O. game will be a shootout go with Brees this time.
1030110
Its pure and simple the good ole 16 manning is great he has more responsibility on a field than any player ever. He is a field general he makes so many calls. However he has struggeled when it counts most. I am a huge Manning fan but until he can win in the post season and win the big one nobody comes close. And Brady had better not ever see light in this argument cuz i could've lead those patriot teams they were so stocked.\n\nYou can't go based on stats alone. Marino had such a lengthy career of course he has all those records only one of which still stands btw. That record will someday fall maybe at the hands of peyton maybe not. Fact is Marino couldn't scramble if he had to move outside the pocket his accuracy plummeted, I'd take a healthy elway over marino any day, at least he knows what if feels like to win the big one.
844693
Peyton Manning for sure, actually, Reggie Wayne, Joseph Addai and Nick Harper
963182
ROMO. Baltimore has great DB's and Palmer should throw at least 2 INT's. Baltimore just shut down Pitt's Pass game and Run game COMPLETELY, so you can't even say that Cincy's run game would balance the pass game out either.\n\nRomo, on the other hand, is going up against a battered Giants team who just gave up 24 points in the 4th quarter to Vince Young (yeah, basically to him only). Romo picked apart TB and even performed well against a fast Indy defense. Look for Romo to throw a pick, but also 2 TDs as the Cowboys will win 30-24.