Who is the better qb: Ben Roethisberger or Peyton Manning?
80827
I say Peyton since he has been with the NFL alot longer but there both great players. Payton has been around a long time and never went to a superbowl and Ben is playing in a superbowl today!
1168523
Yes, but Hasselhoff is the better quarterback.
487723
brett favre or peyton manning
1174611
Peyton Manning-Marvin Harrison.  Some of the most exciting players in the game.  Too bad they cant win in the playoffs.
836454
You'll never win this argument, although one could argue that Roy was certainly more important to his team than Elway was.\n\nThe Broncos, likely, would have won with a lesser QB in their Super Bowl wins (now, we're not talking JP Lossman here...maybe Dilfer or McNair)...where as Roy was the one who put the Avs/Nords over the top to win their first drink from Lord Stanley.\n\nBoth players had baggage...Roy's exit from Montreal was ugly...Elway's issues with Dan Reeves almost made him exit Denver.  However, football is a much more popular sport in Denver and, unless you are comparing the likes of Bobby Orr to Tom Brady, no hockey player could ever win this...and even Orr wins only by a hair there.
793053
If you go by the number of  Super Bowl rings, then the answer is Tom Brady. If you go by stats, the answer is Peyton Manning.  Actually the most efficient quarterback in the NFL right now, based on the QB rating formula, is Tony Romo of the Cowboys, followed by  Manning. However, Romo has played fewer games this season\nthan Manning, so I would say the answer right now is Manning.
936788
Peyton Manning is the man!
962219
Tom Brady knows one thing and one thing only, "JUST WIN". He doesn't care about his own stats, QB passer rating, completion percentages etc. He'll do what it takes to win a game. Peyton Manning is a better QB based on numbers and stats. But if I compare them intuitively, I favor Tom Brady over Peyton Manning because he just wins. Also another thing to note is Bill Belichick is the key reason for Tom Brady's success. If Bill Belichick was coacing Peyton Manning, Peyton will keep winning every Super Bowl. Reading from my comments you'll see that I adore both Tom Brady & Peyton Manning.
62640
Ben Rothinberger has to be the favorite but Jerome Bettis has to be the darkhorse. The Super Bowl might be his last game and with a decent performance he would definelty be the sentimental pick.
777721
Has to be the Giants.... \n\nIf they lose this week, then it goes down in history as one of the greatest sports implosions in history. Worse than the Red Sox this year...\n\nI don't care what anyone says... romo is no Manning.
726993
Hard to go against Peyton, but Brees against the Bengals I would have to go with Brees. The Cincy-N.O. game will be a shootout go with Brees this time.
810844
This is a very difficult question. \n\nIf you look at both side to side it is almost like looking at Joe Montana and Dan Marino. Montana, like Brady, has the Championship rings. Also, just like Montana, Brady has constantly had great coaches and a decent cast of co-players around him. \n\nManning and Marino have not had that luxury. Both Marino and Manning are regular season statical giants. Breaking pretty much every passing record, neither seemed to have the right mix of players to get through the playoffs. Also until Dungy, Manning never really had great coaching.\n\nIn truth the answer to this opinion question lies in whether or not you feel that Championships or Records make greatness.\n\nI am of the belief that records make greatness so I would CURRENTLY choose Manning as the better of the two.\n\nHowever, Brady is still very young, so the jury is still out.
956565
Hasselbeck is definitely warming up to something good as of late. Roethlisberger isn't playing like he even deserves to be in the NFL. Then again, both of these guys are capable of big games out of nowhere.
751809
Sorry dude but NEITHER!\n Peyton Manning is da man!
1161198
i like the colts\n\npeyton manning is awesome
584146
Tom Brady of the New England Patriots. Simply because he knows how to win. Three Super Bowl Championships proves that. Even though Peyton Manning has more talent, he chokes in big games. Thus I give the edge to Brady.
97349
2 time MVP Peyton Manning.