I'm considering it for use with the Samsung Galaxy s4 with the Otterbox COMMUTER case on it. Will it be too large since Defender is mentioned?
646997
Not really sure. I have the defender case and it fits great. Do love the case though. Very nice.
646998
I feel that it should work just fine i am about to purchase the putter cover
646999
I honestly do not know if it can be used with the Otterbox Commuter case on it. However, I will tell you that I have my Galaxy S4 in a white wallet-type holder (which also has side pockets inside of it where I keep my driver's license and a couple of credit cards). Even in this white wallet-type holder, it fits perfectly inside of this black-leather belt holder. When I ordered this black holder, I was like you and did not know if my white wallet-type holder would fit inside of it. But I figured, for the price, even if it did not fit inside of it, I would just take my Galaxy S4 out of the white wallet and use the black holder by itself. I truly love this black holder, and I don't regret ordering it :) Good luck deciding what to do!
647000
I purchased it because the outter box clip was just wasn't working for me but I found this case and it fit very good and well protected.
647001
This belt case is perfect for the Samsung Galaxy s4 with the Otterbox. Plus it gives you comfort and keeps your phone secure. Hope this helps
206125
The otterbox case would probably be too big. It would probably work with a slim case
1806398
Sorry, I'm pretty sure the Defender will not fit. The Commuter is a bit smaller in all dimensions and fits perfectly.
1322084
Well i bought it for my S3 and i put it in a otterbox commuter case and it still fits so i think it can hold in it. The S4 is bigger so i think it can hold in it for sure as it would be as big as the my s3 with the otterbox case.
1661598
The Otterbox Defender will fit; you just need to remove the foam insert inside the hard shell. It will be a tight fit, but it WILL fit.
860318
Yes it will fit with the commuter but just a tad roomy but not much. I have the defender but used and returned the otter box commuter case for more protection.
32837
I do not have an otterbox defender case on my Galaxy S4 but I do have a case and it does fit with the case that I have on the phone
756996
I have a thin case and it fits perfectly. In not sure how thick the defender case is.
2035693
I don't know how big a "defender" case is. Unless makes your iPhone really fat, like over 3/4", or unless the case interferes with the Bluetooth connection, I think you should be OK. You can pull the little holder thingy out of the carrying case/device stand pretty far.
150292
You will not be able to fit any phone with an otterbox case. It will be too bulky. You can take it out of the case and put it back on when done riding
1352659
The dock will work with the otter commuter and definitely not with a defender. I had to shave the corners off of the dock at the plug in and in doing so voided any warranty. If you and not handy with a file or Dermal the answer is no. You would have to remove the case every time.
856285
There is a better chance of this if you have the defender case. However, the commuter case is not meant to totally protect your phone from breaking.
969280
No. The otterbox makes your phone hecka thick. With my hubbys Galaxy Note it fits fine...but with his Otterbox on it...no way - its too large.
1453048
I am using it with several Ballistic Cases. The thinner cases work, but the thicker cases (Tough Jacket series) do not. I think the Defender is probably equivalent to the latter and will be a problem, though I can't be sure.
2120925
I don't think so. The defender case is noticeably thicker than the commuter series.
197472
I have a Galaxy S4 in an Otterbox Defender Case and it fits easily. I am sure that it would fit a smaller, lower profile phone quite well.
142610
My husband has this case on his s4 as well and has never had an issue sliding it in his pocket. It does make the phone thicker but not as much as the defender series will. I don't think it's a deal breaker.