Do you think the s4 would fit in here in a commuter Otterbox case?
652964
It will not. You'll have to take off the outter box and place phone in as normal. Also, pouring your phone upside makes it easier to use the touch screen while running.
652965
It would be a pretty tight fit but would probably work with a lot of finagling. I don't think it would be something that I would want to do on a daily basis, every time I worked out though.
652966
I think it would fit, a little tight. I take the case off on mine when i am going to use it
317334
It is a tight squeeze, but it does fit. I do think the manufacturer should have allowed a little more room, with the number of people using cases the size of Otterboxes.
1640469
It would probably fit snuggly, but I think you could still get it in and out fairly easy. I don't have the Otter for my S4, so I couldn't say for sure. I had the Defender series with my old HTC and it looks like it would have fit. Sorry I can't be of more help!
1120186
*shakes head* No. It is a snug fit with the Otterbox Commuter case. There's no way the bulkier defender will fit.
1927529
I have my EVO in an Otterbox Commuter case and it is very snug but it will fit.
1300463
It fits my S3 with an otterbox Commuter. The S4 is only 1mm wider and the same height so I would say you would be OK to purchase it.
1519721
My s4 fits tightly in the case. If a battery extended a mm more, it would not fit.
1086970
I have an Otterbox commuter case and it fits just fine. I am pretty sure a protector will fit fine too. Just be aware that the case starts showing it wear at about 6 months. Its cheap enough to replace however
490441
I have a Samsung galaxy s4 in a "commuter" style Otterbox and it fits over it just fine. You don't get a full circle from the fisheye though but this is not caused by the case but rather the lens on the phone it's self
7621
That's based entirely on your preference. I myself have the OtterBox commuter case and it fits perfectly. I couldn't be happier.
1688606
The Commuter Case might fit... I have one at home I can try and let you know. I honestly like this case better than my Otterbox Commuter though. The buttons are much easier to push and the whole feel of the case is better.Worth the buy in my opinion. My Dad bought his first and then I bought one... my son took mine and I got another one. Hope this helps you out! Stefeni
590602
Yes Aaron, my S3 has the Otterbox Commuter case on it and fits great in this Holster. I've been very happy with it and have been using the 3 of them together for the last 9 months.
153903
I have the S4 and with my case on I can get it in the pocket but it's an extremely tight fit. Without the case I bet it would be easier.
1119010
It is a very tight fit, but mine does fit. I have an Otter Box Commuter case on my phone.
1012983
it barely holds my Galaxy S3 in the otterbox and I believe the s4 is slightly bigger. I'd have to say probably not.
2113225
We don't have an Otterbox case on our S4 but it actually comes with a case that it screws into over the camera lens. To use it in a different case you would have to just hold it and line it up exactly but the case for it is decent. Just a flat black case. But I think it needs to be the case that comes with it so it can be directly attached.
625068
I'm not sure. I can stuff my S4 into the armband while the Otterbox Commuter is still on the phone. It's not a perfect fit but it's still functional if you don't feel like pulling your case off.