If my memory serves me right the formula was different. The shampoo used to be green in color, much more intense in oil content, and watery. Now it's pearly white and thick like many on the market, and it does not smell as intense, so I am assuming...
640964
Idk. Mine is greenish and watery. It's not white at all. I do give bottle a shake or 2 to mix it. Maybe it's settlement? I haven ordered another bottle yet. Maybe ask company if they have chg the color.
528945
If you ask me, there is no change at all. I used the shampoo it's worse when you had a thin hair what happen is your hair will get tangled and it's very difficult to untangle it, what you have to do is pull it out. What they should do is to mix shampoo and conditioner together. For me it's not working at all.
1515865
The formula is different and this one is more likely to cause problems for people with extremely sensitive skin. Only the bottles labeled "Classic Gentle Formula" with the green sticker have the old formula!
627225
It used to be clear, used to have classic printed on the bottle and it used to smell better. Now this product just smells bad and is milk white not slightly white but milk white. I have tried to go through my past orders so I can get the same shampoo as what I have always got before but every past order says I purchased this. I have only purchased this once. All the ones before had classic printed on the bottle.
660970
Ok that shampoo is not that thick. I have very long hair and use about a 50 cent size dollop in my hand. But your hair must really be wet for it so suds up and remember to shake the bottle. The smell is a little clinical but it doesn't bother me as I look for stuff that has no real big fragrance.
731476
No it is not the same, but the product works really well for me. It just seems like there is more orange/red in the current bottles.
2066474
Very similar. It has a floral smell but my dog with skin that reacts to even hypo shampoo doesn't react to it at all. I've used both extensively. this is very effective
1399860
Are you saying that they have a new white formula? I did not know. In any case- it does not absorb like the old formula. I use it day and night and this will not work for me. Very sad if this is the new formula. I will look into it on line.
140583
Yes, I noticed this, too. I'm wondering if it's maybe a formulary change that came along at the same time as the new packaging, because I've been buying these from Amazon for years and there wasn't the awful smell before with the other packaging.
568880
The shampoo and conditioner both have a sweet flowery smell to them. I haven't used the packet in a long while, but I seem to recall that it does not have much of an odor at all.
647955
In their old formula (which they still had not that long ago), there was no fragrance at all. However, this new bottle that you see pictured here apparently came with a new formula and it does have a very slight apple fragrance (in my opinion). The company will tell you that nothing has changed with the formula, however, I have multiple chemical sensitivities and can pick up on very tiny changes that maybe most of the population would not notice. The new formula also lathers more easily, so something definitely changed. However, I still do use the shampoo. After you rinse, it does not leave a fragrance on you, but you do smell it a little while you're lathering up. I can't use their conditioner anymore. The bottle smells like a mild form of windex to me and I react to it now. Their old formula was also good. I use Dessert Essense fragrance free conditioner now and love it. It also has kind of a light oatmeal smell and conditions much better than this brand (does not leave a fragrance after rinsing). I may switch over to their shampoo as well in the future.
733531
Rebecca, I purchased my shampoo some time ago, when I wrote my original review. The same 1/2 gallon is still going strong. Hair color still holding. Sorry not to be of much help.
188231
I believe the label was different and listed green tea and oatmeal as part of the formula now the label just says "Sapone" soap in Italian for sensitive skin, I honestly can feel or smell a difference between he current offering and the ones I had years ago. it is my favorite offering from Proaso.
1132143
When I looked into this before, it seemed like there was some proprietary difference in terms of cleaning agents, but practically speaking, this advanced formula differs in that it is scented. I used a bottle of the white stuff and it had a chemical smell for a few days and subsided. The advanced just had the perfume smell that was crazy strong for the first week, but gently lingers for months afterwards (if you use a lot of it). I'm also betting a $10 bottle of the white stuff is a smaller bottle.
864802
The shampoo is just like any other. The reason We use it is our well is high in iron and my daughters hair was turning orange. All other functions of the shampoo are standard but it was gentle on her hair and returned it from orange to blonde. I hope this helps.
1164270
Hello Mc: I cannot answer that question because I don't have the bottle with me anymore. But, if you go on their website, I am sure you can find the ingredients and a lot of information about this shampoo. I hope I helped, somehow.
1578044
I have somewhat thick and a lot of it, Caucasian hair. Mine has been colored a lot but wasn't recently before using this... It wasn't the keratin formula that did the most damage, but rather the cleansing shampoo in the beginning. It made my hair feel like HAY. I would honestly not use this again. It wasn't worth the results for me.