will it fit inside the case with the otterbox commuter series case on the phone? remember the commuter case is the slimmer model of the otterbox cases
1123168
I have the Otter box series above the commuter and it fits fine. It's tight but fits.
1123169
I do not know. But I do know it is big, clumsy and I will never use it unless I go out in a boat or on a ship.
1123170
Ok I have the galaxy note 2 with a hard case it will not fit with the case on but my wife has the samsung galaxy s 2 and it did fit in the waterproof case I hope I could help out
735946
Im, not sure. I have an iPhone 5 in a Otterbox commuter case and it fits that.
461063
It will fit. I have a regular s5 and there is room all the way around it, especially in the top for the added length of the active; I also have am Otterbox Commuter case on mine. Operating it inside the case shouldn't be an issue either. It isn't perfect so I usually get mine ready before inserting it. Hope this helps.
310425
I don't have a commuter case but from what I can tell the Symmetry is thinner. It's still protects phone however, it's not bulky like some of the other Otterboxes I've seen! (And they have really pretty choices ;) )
1030564
Yes. I have mine in a slim case and it slips in and out easily. It might be a tighter fit with a bulky case, but I'd guess that it would still work.These things are great, BTW. I throw my phone around all the time, accidentally, of course, and it protects it beautifully. Highly recommend!
800686
Hi Robin,I have an HTC One and the Otterbox commuter fits perfectly and has saved my phone about 100 times by now.
1650099
I have the defender, and it's fine, the commuter is thinner, so it will be OK, I also have the spigen neo hybrid, which is similar to the commuter, and it fits perfectly, so there shouldn't be a problem
1653307
I'm not sure if the slim is designed to fit in there the same way as the original - you might want to look for a slim-specific case.
456011
When I ordered my Otterbox Commuter replacement I made sure it was the same thing, even to the color, that I had before. When I received it, it fit exactly. If you have a different size phone then you need to take that into account. I hope that helps.
1907623
The phone should fit with a slim case on it. I'm familiar with Otter Box and I think that it may be too large. HOWEVER, i purchased this for an iPhone 6 Plus and it did not fit. The return process was very easy and convenient though. Try it....if not, return it. Hope this helped.
1249628
I don't have the Otterbox Commuter but I can confidently say that it won't fit with this back cover.
1420914
I have a slim armor on my phone and it fits Snug in case. Same dimensions ,roughly 1/2" thick. Hopefully. This will help!!!!
2049047
No, you need to remove the phone from any casing for it to fit. And I think it is better to use it that way. I tried to insert my phone with my elaggio slimfit casing but it just won't fit. An otterbox is definitely thicker.
1955353
I have the otterbox commuter case and it does not work with that. But the case is pretty easy off and on so I don't mind. It does have a snap out plastic section so I think it is designed for a slim case. I friend of mine down the hall has this case:Spigen Slim Armor Case for Galaxy Note 3 - Infinity White (SGP10459)and with the plastic section out this dock connected to the phone with the case on without a problem.
1300463
It fits my S3 with an otterbox Commuter. The S4 is only 1mm wider and the same height so I would say you would be OK to purchase it.
528773
NO it will not. I have the otterbox commuter series case. the phone with case barely fits the VicTsing holder with the "adapter" removed. You have to do some gentle forcing. and, it will not mate with the USB Power connector. I am returning the VicTsing for a refund.
590602
Yes Aaron, my S3 has the Otterbox Commuter case on it and fits great in this Holster. I've been very happy with it and have been using the 3 of them together for the last 9 months.