Does anyone know how this compares to Cardinal Laboratories Pet Botanics Whole Grain Rolled Dog Food?
1605401
Am not familiar with Pet Botanics but my understanding is that dogs are not obligate carnivores but they are also not able to digest grains efficiently so I do not understand the reason for anything for dogs that is grain based. Most pet nutritionists are advising dog owneers to stay away from foods containing grain. The name of the company sounds like a means to an end: convince the pet owner that they have some special way to process grain that allows dogs' digestive system to metabolize grains???? Mother nature recommends meat based foods for both dogs and cats. My 2 centsP.S. Both of my dogs love red barn products. Am not familiar with Pet Botanics but my understanding is that dogs are not obligate carnivores but they are also not able to digest grains efficiently so I do not understand the reason for anything for dogs that is grain based. Most pet nutritionists are advising dog owneers to stay away from foods containing grain. The name of the company sounds like a means to an end: convince the pet owner that they have some special way to process grain that allows dogs' digestive system to metabolize grains???? Mother nature recommends meat based foods for both dogs and cats. My 2 centsP.S. Both... » Read More Am not familiar with Pet Botanics but my understanding is that dogs are not obligate carnivores but they are also not able to digest grains efficiently so I do not understand the reason for anything for dogs that is grain based. Most pet nutritionists are advising dog owneers to stay away from foods containing grain. The name of the company sounds like a means to an end: convince the pet owner that they have some special way to process grain that allows dogs' digestive system to metabolize grains???? Mother nature recommends meat based foods for both dogs and cats. My 2 centsP.S. Both of my dogs love red barn products. « Show Less
1605402
Am not familiar with Pet Botanics but my understanding is that dogs are not obligate carnivores but they are also not able to digest grains efficiently so I do not understand the reason for anything for dogs that is grain based. Most pet nutritionists are advising dog owneers to stay away from foods containing grain. The name of the company sounds like a means to an end: convince the pet owner that they have some special way to process grain that allows dogs' digestive system to metabolize grains???? Mother nature recommends meat based foods for both dogs and cats. My 2 cents P.S. Both of my dogs love red barn products.
1605403
I been using Cardinal Laboratories Pet Botanics for the last few years. Last month I went to buy more and they jumped the price 10 dollars! So I decided to try this Redbarn brand. My dogs LOVES it! I think they are liking it even better than the Pet Botanics. They look exactly the same and both smell about the same. So -- I'm getting ready to buy more!
1220032
No, barley is a grain. We tried it with our dog and she didn't do very well on it. It's a great product, just not for dogs with grain sensitivity.
713672
Yes, absolutely! I have a 17 lb dachshund/yorkie mix, and he LOVES it! I was on Organix for years, which he ate. Then I switched to Newman's Own after I read all the positive reviews here. After that, he refused to eat the small amount of Organix I had left--even after I added some bacon fat to it! Have used Newman's Own for years, and he just loves it. Highly recommended. (FYI, I use the advanced formula, because my dog is 10 years old.)P.S. Don't get the 7 lb bag. You can get the 12 lb bag for only 3 dollars more, and there will be free shipping--so it'll actually be cheaper than the 7 lb bag! I get the 12 lb bag and split it into 2 bags when I get it, so it doesn't go stale. Yes, absolutely! I have a 17 lb dachshund/yorkie mix, and he LOVES it! I was on Organix for years, which he ate. Then I switched to Newman's Own after I read all the positive reviews here. After that, he refused to eat the small amount of Organix I had left--even after I added some bacon fat to it! Have used Newman's Own for years, and he just loves it. Highly recommended. (FYI, I use the advanced formula, because my dog is 10 years old.)P.S. Don't get the 7 lb bag. You can get the 12 lb bag for only 3 dollars more, and there will be free shipping--so it'll actually be cheaper... » Read More Yes, absolutely! I have a 17 lb dachshund/yorkie mix, and he LOVES it! I was on Organix for years, which he ate. Then I switched to Newman's Own after I read all the positive reviews here. After that, he refused to eat the small amount of Organix I had left--even after I added some bacon fat to it! Have used Newman's Own for years, and he just loves it. Highly recommended. (FYI, I use the advanced formula, because my dog is 10 years old.)P.S. Don't get the 7 lb bag. You can get the 12 lb bag for only 3 dollars more, and there will be free shipping--so it'll actually be cheaper than the 7 lb bag! I get the 12 lb bag and split it into 2 bags when I get it, so it doesn't go stale. « Show Less
1653070
Hi! I recently rescued a dog with skin allergies that turned into a skin infection. He was on benedryl, antibiotics, petco healthy skin vitamins, AND fish oil. I switched to purina's sensitive skin and everything got alot better but I was concerned he still had some itching and there were still troublesome ingredients. I went to a highly reputable local dog food seller and after hearing all the options and reading rave reviews chose TOTW Pacific stream. It was 40 dollars for a 33 lb bag. in less than a week my dog stopped itching, dandruff went away, and he had more energy than ever! no more vet bills, medicine, or twice daily pills! yes its a little more expensive but the Pacific Stream formula saved me and my dog from serious stress from allergies! All his fur has grown back and I get daily compliments from strangers on walks about how great his coat looks! i only have him on Pacific stream, but I know that one helps with allergies
1688648
Not according to the label--main ingredients or inactive ingredients. It has Glucosamine, MSM, Chondroitin, Ascorbic Acid, and Manganese. The inactive ingredients includes nutmeg, allspice, brewers yeast (which is good to keep fleas and tickets away, but in a larger quantity than this probably has), chicken liver flavor, silicon dioxide, and stearic acid. I do not have my dog on any pain medications and she is doing well on this by itself. One, twice a day, whereas before I had her on another "advanced hip and joint" compound, 3 tablets , 3 times a day and she still had issues.... Hope this is helpful. Not according to the label--main ingredients or inactive ingredients. It has Glucosamine, MSM, Chondroitin, Ascorbic Acid, and Manganese. The inactive ingredients includes nutmeg, allspice, brewers yeast (which is good to keep fleas and tickets away, but in a larger quantity than this probably has), chicken liver flavor, silicon dioxide, and stearic acid. I do not have my dog on any pain medications and she is doing well on this by itself. One, twice a day, whereas before I had her on another "advanced hip and joint" compound, 3 tablets , 3 times a day and she still had issues....... » Read More Not according to the label--main ingredients or inactive ingredients. It has Glucosamine, MSM, Chondroitin, Ascorbic Acid, and Manganese. The inactive ingredients includes nutmeg, allspice, brewers yeast (which is good to keep fleas and tickets away, but in a larger quantity than this probably has), chicken liver flavor, silicon dioxide, and stearic acid. I do not have my dog on any pain medications and she is doing well on this by itself. One, twice a day, whereas before I had her on another "advanced hip and joint" compound, 3 tablets , 3 times a day and she still had issues.... Hope this is helpful. « Show Less
1032490
I don't have a bag on hand at the moment, but this is copied from the Dog Food Adviser website. My dogs are very spoiled and won't eat most dog food. Any human food yes, but not dog food. Wellness also makes a reduced calorie dry food for small breeds. I always check at the dog food adviser website for food analysis and ratings before buying. Amazon has a great selection of foods and treats but it's helpful to do your research first. Wellness Core Original Formula Dry Dog Food Estimated Dry Matter Nutrient Content Protein 0 100 38 Fat 0 100 18 Carbs 0 100 36 Ingredients: Deboned turkey, turkey meal, chicken meal, peas, potatoes, dried ground potatoes, chicken fat (preserved with mixed tocopherols), tomato pomace, chicken liver, natural chicken flavor, flaxseed, salmon oil, carrots, sweet potatoes, kale, broccoli, spinach, parsley, apples, blueberries, vitamins [vitamin E supplement, beta-carotene, niacin, d-calcium pantothenate, vitamin A supplement, riboflavin, vitamin D3 supplement, vitamin B12 supplement, pyridoxine hydrochloride, thiamine mononitrate, ascorbic acid (vitamin C), biotin, folic acid], minerals [zinc proteinate, zinc sulfate, iron proteinate, ferrous sulfate, copper sulfate, copper proteinate, manganese proteinate, manganese sulfate, sodium selenite, calcium iodate], choline chloride, mixed tocopherols added to preserve freshness, glucosamine hydrochloride, chondroitin sulfate, taurine, chicory root extract, Yucca schidigera extract, dried Lactobacillus plantarum fermentation product, dried Enterococcus faecium fermentation product, dried Lactobacillus casei fermentation product, dried Lactobacillus acidophilus fermentation product, rosemary extract Fiber (estimated dry matter content) = 4.4% Red items when present indicate controversial ingredients Estimated Nutrient Content Method Protein Fat Carbs Guaranteed Analysis 34% 16% NA Dry Matter Basis 38% 18% 36% Calorie Weighted Basis 32% 37% 31%
1994702
Janet,So sorry but my dogs have not had Southwest - they have had wetlands in their diet and have loved it, I usually mix it with either the dry High Prarie or the dry Pacific stream. Chose this dog food as a result of checking out dog food advisor.com and finding a great quality dog food then researched all prices and availability on Amazon. I know it doesn't answer your question, but perhaps helps in other ways. Thanks
2114793
I have no idea. My Yorkie has peanut and other food related allergies. This was the 2nd brand of food I tried but I never tried Natural Balance. So I don't know if it's better but I can tell you she does enjoy the Royal Canin
1098882
MAX Has more ingredients go to the phycox site and read info on it - I was very impressed especially I have a older dog with an injury. I was using Phycox before but no the max then I researched it and switched. Now my vet carries it too. Great stuff.
850941
We feed our English Mastiff the Pacific Stream formula as he wasn't able to tolerate the High Prairie formula (allergies). We tried other salmon and fish formulas from other manufacturers and this is the only one that he does well on. He's been on this food for over two years now (of course he's now on the adult formula), and at a bit over 200lbs, he's very happy & healthy.
1934187
Sorry I cant answer as I put my kibbles in a big container and throw the original bag it came in away. All I know is my lab loves it and she lost weight. Her coat is shiny and healthy so I know it has the nutrients she needs. You could go to the web site and check all the nutritional values or even contact the company. Recommend this dog food!!
912459
Buy it from Amazon. It's cheaper and was fresher than when I have bought in local pet stores.
1100959
I really do not know. Our dog was real healthy and she died a natural death at the age of 14. We always fed her Premium Edge and she had no health problems. The label should tell if it contains probiotics. Sorry I could not be more help.
452357
Sorry, don't know but I switched to NutraCares Nutrition Krill Oil. I give it to my four legged friend due to joint issues and it seems to work better for him -- don't know why though.
352424
My cats seem to like "Ocean" flavors better then chicken, but also I like that the salmon has the Omega 3 for a softer and shinier coat. This is my opinion, but I feel that it is legit.
1110108
Per Halo comment: The company writes "we are not ordering new products at this time..." So is this just a packaging facility? Where does their "product" ship from, I'm hoping not China. I was just about to order MSM but will hold off until I can find out. Haven't forgotten the pet food fiasco yet.
156438
I don't know - I stopped using it very shortly after I bought it because at the time it had corn gluten meal which gave my dog a yeast infection. I have been feeding him the excellent grain-free foods from Fromms and Merrick's.