We have four kids, the oldest two are toe walkers with semi-flat feet. The doctor just informed me I need to get them some arch support, but am concerned because most of the inserts I see have heel support as well and I am not sure that would be good...
527408
I don't know about toe-walkers. Our granddaughter has flat feet and her osteopathic doctor recommended arch support, alongside the monthly treatment she received. We are extremely happy with this product, which helped a great deal. our granddaughter loves it and has now learned that if she does not wear them, her feet ache. Her arch is gradually developing. We got her a size 11. She still wears it even though her shoe size is 11 1/2. Janet
508720
I do not wear arch supports. But i do not think these will go over them. In some of my shoes where this insole doesn't work I use the pedag gel metatarsal pads. They may work for you as they can sit under the arch support. They are one size only and not such a good fit in very slim shoes, but you can trim them back a bit. It is really a bit of trial and error if you need another type of support as well. There are other insoles on the market which have both arch and metatarsal suppots but they are not as thin as pedag ones.
2281358
They would work great for fallen arches! If you were born with flat feet the arch might be too high for you.
474624
Emilio, all I can say about these inserts are they make your feet feel sooooooooooooooo much better for wearing them. At the end of the day you can still smile, but I can offer you further help. If you will change shoes mid day and wear a different pair of shoes (with inserts as well) your feet will not tire and hurt as much. Possibly with both aids you will experience much less pain. I am guessing that you are on your feet all day (or night).
2281552
Probably not. The rise in the arch is almost considered extreme. I have quite the arch and putting all my weight (220, 6'1") on the arch support of the insert can hurt your feet in the wrong shoes. It would be painful for someone with little or no arch. You are better off trying a different Dr. Scholls foot insert and not this one specifically.
757139
For shoe comfort, make sure you have a shoe with a large toe box like some new balances. Also, it would be wise to have them on if you go and try on new shoes.
1508105
go to the higher size (9). The insert is only 3/4 length. it will support heel, arch and padding below the toe pad (where your toes begin). Doesn't go full length of shoe. Don't worry, it won't be too big for any of your shoes. Switch them into whatever pair of shoes you are going to wear. Gives great support and padding. Like a new shoe! enjoy......
474625
These are gel like inserts with little arch support. They are made with pressure point areas on the bottom. For me personally they have helped with my Plantar Fasciitis more than I would have ever thought.
1959958
Not a Dr by any means, but you've stated too different but sometimes related conditions.Traditional wisdom would say flat feet equals low arches, ergo YELLOW but you should always consult your Dr.
571407
If you're really flat-foot challenged, I would recommend going to an arthropod who is a pro at fitting orthotics and is connected with good labs who make them. I've tried buying them in stores and on line. But my feet and ankles are a mess, and the best solutions have come from the doctors.
1508103
Neither, I tried them and they are worthless. That's my opinion. I need an orthotic arch support and these were not the answer - I emphasize - for me. But, go bigger than smaller!
1037847
Yes, these are more of an arch support. Everyone's arch is higher or lower than someone else. Since one size wont fit all, they try to make a few different sizes of arch support so you can try to get one that is somewhat close. If you need an arch support these can help provide some relief. If you need an arch support and would like a professional fit like a doctor would prescribe go to Surethotic.com. They will make a support that is an exact fit and will last 10 times longer.
711009
If you have not been diagnosed with plantar fasciitis, then this will help, but spenco polysorb insoles will do a much better job. They are a complete insole, whereas the profoot arch support are only 3/4 of an insole. I still have the profoot arch supports but I only use them in shoes without heel support. Do not invest in expensive insoles. I did and was greatly disappointed. Experiment.
1396617
Absolutely, go for it. I did, about, 15-yrs ago and now my once FLAT FEET have natural arches. Don't rush it, wear your orthotics for a half hour on day one and then go from there, depending on how you do. I've purchased all my orthotics from ArchCrafters, except for once. I recall that exception, orthotics from another company, was a total mistake cause I gave them to the dumpster. Not the ArchCrafters ; I still use my first pair of their orthotics. Right, they do not wear out. HillbillyPS. The caviot from Amazon, "not suitable for flat feet", I must assume, is to protect against law suits. Lawyers... Absolutely, go for it. I did, about, 15-yrs ago and now my once FLAT FEET have natural arches. Don't rush it, wear your orthotics for a half hour on day one and then go from there, depending on how you do. I've purchased all my orthotics from ArchCrafters, except for once. I recall that exception, orthotics from another company, was a total mistake cause I gave them to the dumpster. Not the ArchCrafters ; I still use my first pair of their orthotics. Right, they do not wear out. HillbillyPS. The caviot from Amazon, "not suitable for flat feet", I must assume, is to... » Read More Absolutely, go for it. I did, about, 15-yrs ago and now my once FLAT FEET have natural arches. Don't rush it, wear your orthotics for a half hour on day one and then go from there, depending on how you do. I've purchased all my orthotics from ArchCrafters, except for once. I recall that exception, orthotics from another company, was a total mistake cause I gave them to the dumpster. Not the ArchCrafters ; I still use my first pair of their orthotics. Right, they do not wear out. HillbillyPS. The caviot from Amazon, "not suitable for flat feet", I must assume, is to protect against law suits. Lawyers... « Show Less
271155
I believe you would benefit from wearing these with your inserts, unless they won't fit in the shoe. I have terrible heel pain, and these DO help me.
914142
Yes. I have low arches and basically flat feet. These are a little uncomfortable at first, but after breaking in are now very comgortable.. Hope you have the same results!
977916
I have high arches, and they work well for my feet... I'm not a podiatrist, but I suspect the hard arch support might be a little much for flat feet