What would be the right size for a Samsung S5 with a slim rubber case?
796630
Not really. I have an S5 and it fits okay without a case, and barely with a slim rubber case. Another problem is that the case covers the earphone jack and you have to wrestle with it to plug it in. I've also noticed that the case is scratching up my frame. It has a plastic leather bottom instead of a soft one. This is a great idea. I love being able to easily carry my wallet and keys without much extra weight. This particular model is just not that well thought out. I'm switching to a standard bar mounted smart phone holder.
796631
I bought the large and like it for phone and otterbox on it. More room for tube and tools.
2196232
Not sure how big your case is. I have mine in slim Incase and it fits fine. Pretty much sized to fit snugly.
1698766
It would probably fit, but imperfectly. My Galaxy S5 (with Otter Box Commuter) is 5.75 inches long and it fits the case perfectly. The extra quarter inch will allow the cover flap to close, but with only about half of the velcro being used to secure the closure. The width and depth should not be a problem.
192379
You can enter Ballistic SG Maxx Galaxy S5 in the search box and you should find one that fits.
1189317
3 5/16 × 6 × 5/8 big enough for the S-5 with an otter box, it is ex-large but not HEAVY DUTY . Thin soft nylon & elastic and only single stitching. I purchased 4 and have had 2 come apart already. I would like to find some made out of a heavy Ballistic nylon & Double stitched for durability. hope this helps you out with your decision.
272044
I use this case for my Galaxy S5 with a rubber-type case and it fits fine (a little tight first, but then breaks ok).I guess that the iPhone 5 model should bethe same, too.
1667529
Jeff, I've got an S3 and keep the case on it and insert it. Plenty of room left over.
659253
I'm not sure about the Galaxy S5 fitting. I WILL say this, order a size bigger in this belt. I have regrets that I did not. This product runs small!
1102161
My Galaxy S5 with Otterbox Defender case is 6" long. It's a squeeze, but it fits. It pulls the liner inside out when I take the phone out, so the only other things I can put in it have to go in the thin side pockets, and not the main compartment. Gleason pretty much nailed it.
599247
I have a Trident case, which seems to be about the thickness of an Otterbox commuter. It just fits my Samsung S5. I would think that a normal Otterbox would be a stretch to fit.
2045361
No too small. It just fits S4. it's a great case for the s4 but it does kind of kill your phone signal. But like I said no it does nIt fit the note
2163028
Sure my S5 had a case and it fine...its adjustable...but it will be heavy and might bring down the visir
2250735
It's not quite 35 cm X 25 cm (maybe more like 32 X 23) but that's bigger than 27 cm X 17 cm, so your Galaxy should fit with some room to spare.
162198
I used mine with the Galaxy Note 3 which is rather large. Haven't seen an S5 but I can't imagine that it is any larger.
164502
It is my understanding that the S5 Active had slightly different specs. I would search by S5 Active to find the right case.
1494671
I have an S5 SPORT it does fit (barely) with out the case on. With the case it is pretty tight and my case is slim. But there are not many options for the S5 Sport so I guess you take what you can get.
953240
It holds the S3, but not tightly, so I'd say 5.5" by 2.75" L X W. The side buttons never get pressed by the case. It is 1/2 inch deep, which allows the phone to drop in, but it tapers toward the bottom. The sides are a slightly elastic material, so a shell case covering on the phone would fit, but a rubbery armor case may be too big. When the flap is up, an inch of the phone sticks out, making it easy to pull straight out. The clip on mine has gotten a couple of rust spots from sweat, so a stainless clip would be a nice design change.