compared to other collars this style which is better for lab that pulls?
110115
I bought this for my 9 month yellow lab. He was backing out of his collar. This has been the perfect solution. When he pulls, it tightens around his neck like a chocker.
110116
I have labs that pull also. This collar prevents the dog from backing out of it and getting loose. Mine still pulled with this collar. My vet recommended the easy walk harness and it works like a charm. It makes it difficult for them to pull because the strap crosses over their front legs. Amazon has the best prices!!
110117
This style (all fabric Martingale) is good for preventing the dog from backing out, and it is comfortable. A similar construction has the small loop in the front made of chain. It is a little noisy when the chainrattles past the rings, and so gets the dog's attention a bit more. Also, if the collar is adjusted loosely on the dog, the small fabric loop hangs down in sort of a circle. For a strong pulling dog, a better choice, in my opinion, is a prong collar. From all that I've read, the prong collar, despite its looks, is not harmful to the dog. I use one on my dog. I hope that when he matures and is fully trained, I can go back to a full fabric Martingale. This style (all fabric Martingale) is good for preventing the dog from backing out, and it is comfortable. A similar construction has the small loop in the front made of chain. It is a little noisy when the chainrattles past the rings, and so gets the dog's attention a bit more. Also, if the collar is adjusted loosely on the dog, the small fabric loop hangs down in sort of a circle. For a strong pulling dog, a better choice, in my opinion, is a prong collar. From all that I've read, the prong collar, despite its looks, is not harmful to the dog. I use one on my dog. I hope that when he... » Read More This style (all fabric Martingale) is good for preventing the dog from backing out, and it is comfortable. A similar construction has the small loop in the front made of chain. It is a little noisy when the chainrattles past the rings, and so gets the dog's attention a bit more. Also, if the collar is adjusted loosely on the dog, the small fabric loop hangs down in sort of a circle. For a strong pulling dog, a better choice, in my opinion, is a prong collar. From all that I've read, the prong collar, despite its looks, is not harmful to the dog. I use one on my dog. I hope that when he matures and is fully trained, I can go back to a full fabric Martingale. « Show Less
110119
I recommend something with a chain- not completely chain, so they can hear the sound of it pulling closed. Also the harnesses that pull their noses down seem to work for big dogs that already pull. Another bit of advice, don't let them pull you. If the dog is hell bent on going one direction change course with a firm NO. When they quit pulling then they are allowed to make decisions on where the walk will go.
110118
This collar would not be the best for a dog that is pulling all the time. This type of collar works best for a dog that is spooked, it cannot back out of this type of collar.
110120
This is much gentler than a prong collar...it tightens only when pulled. It has worked well for training my large puppy.I would give this a try before going to the more restrictive prong collar.
110121
It works great. My dog is 90lbs and likes to pull and this keeps him in check. It's nice because you can slip it right over their heads and they cant get out of it.
110122
We've had 2 labs. I'm not sure this would break them of pulling but it certainly wouldn't hurt.
110123
For a big dog that pulls, I really like the Gentle Leader, but for general purposes, the martingale is my pick. I used the Gentle Leader to teach my GSD to heel but he always has on the martingale (shown).
1070752
I worry about ALL prong collars falling off, they tend to twist and release themselves. I put a short rope connecting the round ring on the prong collar to another collar (flat buckle or nylon choke) this way If the prong comes loose, the dog will still be connected to the leash. Photo is on the Amazon site for Herm Springer prong collar. Best of luck with your lab! :)
1380012
I think a harness is best for an energetic dog especially if s/he won't be closely supervised. My experience is that the dog is less likely to get tangled, injured or free with a harness as opposed to collar
1237358
The collar is adjustable. Just buy the one appropriate for the size of the dog. It's not magic, but it does help!
1380971
Thank you for your question! This collar is lighter and the contact points are closer together to help better fit a small breed.
1686054
I have a lab and she responds very well to this collar. Our trainer said it's more like a reminder for the dogs. It's not meant to hurt them. But I'm sure if you have to keep tugging at it then eventually your dog would catch on. Our trainer suggested a little leash, it's like 12" long that we connect to it. So we actually pull the little pink leash that's connected to the collar. That way our dog isn't wearing a really long walking leash in the house and it's easier to guide your dog to listen instead of having to grab the chain. The triangle part of the chain goes on the top. With a little patience and consistency I think this collar would help. I have a lab and she responds very well to this collar. Our trainer said it's more like a reminder for the dogs. It's not meant to hurt them. But I'm sure if you have to keep tugging at it then eventually your dog would catch on. Our trainer suggested a little leash, it's like 12" long that we connect to it. So we actually pull the little pink leash that's connected to the collar. That way our dog isn't wearing a really long walking leash in the house and it's easier to guide your dog to listen instead of having to grab the chain. The triangle part of the chain goes on the top. With a... » Read More I have a lab and she responds very well to this collar. Our trainer said it's more like a reminder for the dogs. It's not meant to hurt them. But I'm sure if you have to keep tugging at it then eventually your dog would catch on. Our trainer suggested a little leash, it's like 12" long that we connect to it. So we actually pull the little pink leash that's connected to the collar. That way our dog isn't wearing a really long walking leash in the house and it's easier to guide your dog to listen instead of having to grab the chain. The triangle part of the chain goes on the top. With a little patience and consistency I think this collar would help. « Show Less
1032444
I would get the large the collar is very easy to adjust . The large worked well on our long necked greyhound and on our no neck Boxer..
667027
I am sure the fit for every dog is a bit different. My Hudson looks like a German shorthair pointer - for him it rides a little below his chest in the front which allows for the pull to encourage movement toward me rather than the usual tug of war. It doesn't seem to be uncomfortable for him at all and I prefer it for sure over the chain collar. Other harnesses I've seen just seem to give the dog more body weight to pull with. I like that this one works smarter , not harder.:-)
300266
If you mean width-wise, 3/4" would be ok or 1". Probably just a matter of preference. My dogs pull really hard sometimes, so I like the 1". If you mean length, the collar specificitions will tell you what size it will fit, and you just need to tape measure your dogs neck at the pointyou want the collar to fit to know which size.
876126
I tried to find out as much information about these collars as possible. There is one school of thought that says do NOT get a quick release fastener if you have a strong/aggressive dog cuz it's possible for them to tug so hard that this release comes open. It surely makes putting the collar on and taking it off MUCH easier, I can say for sure. Look at some videos on YouTube for great information. Just measure the dogs neck for sizing. It's no problem to take some links out if it's too large. If you choose too small, you can order extra links as well. I've tried other collars and, believe me, this one has no competition. I tried to find out as much information about these collars as possible. There is one school of thought that says do NOT get a quick release fastener if you have a strong/aggressive dog cuz it's possible for them to tug so hard that this release comes open. It surely makes putting the collar on and taking it off MUCH easier, I can say for sure. Look at some videos on YouTube for great information. Just measure the dogs neck for sizing. It's no problem to take some links out if it's too large. If you choose too small, you can order extra links as well. I've tried other collars and, believe... » Read More I tried to find out as much information about these collars as possible. There is one school of thought that says do NOT get a quick release fastener if you have a strong/aggressive dog cuz it's possible for them to tug so hard that this release comes open. It surely makes putting the collar on and taking it off MUCH easier, I can say for sure. Look at some videos on YouTube for great information. Just measure the dogs neck for sizing. It's no problem to take some links out if it's too large. If you choose too small, you can order extra links as well. I've tried other collars and, believe me, this one has no competition. « Show Less
407610
I have the large for a Labrador I wouldn't go smaller. Pulls easy. Dog loves it. Plus there is room for you to put water bottles inside with the dog. Outside pockets are nice for flat folding water bowls and other items that you might need. It does fold down for storage but I have never done that since we store it in our garage.
268218
If your dog is not likely to be growing into a thicker neck, I would think (but can't be certain) that the small, which claims to go up to 12" and is only 3/4" wide might be the better choice. Otherwise you will have a lot of extra loop hanging down (which dog could get caught on). I have only had experience with the 1" wide large & medium collars. Good luck to you and your canine pal!
152801
Yes it is however we switched to the Perri's solid leather collar because the padding was a little thick and our lab could slip the collar. The solid leather worked better, seems stronger, & I think looks better
331267
I have one of these collars for both of my 75lb dogs. It is the only collar that works EVEN through their thick fur.
97184
Yes it will my dog is only 60 pounds and he loves to pull. He is a plot hound lab retriever mix. I bought this and just like that pulling stopped . The design helps to not hurt him the choke is al the way up the neck. I don't like choke collars but Cesar is right on with this one.
1760934
I have used both for my lab and I personally prefer the xlarge. We just use it for normal fetch type activities though! She seemed to love both.
1692839
I would go with the large one it easily adjusts down to fit dogs neck. This collar worked great for us. used shock only a couple of times. Our Lab Responded well to the correction tone In five weeks we were basically done with the collar but still good to have around 5 stars