Is the stainless steel pump superior to the cast iron pump?
781312
No, the cast iron pump and stainless steel pump are equal. The price of the stainless steel pump was pennies more when I bought it.
781313
it appears to me that the motor housing is stainless and the pump impeller housing is cast iron; mine's worked quite well here in FL; it replaced a pump with a plastic housing that only lasted 2 yrs before housing failed
2262435
I purchased the titanium because I have cast iron and it works beautifully. Can't speak about the black ones, but the other answer offers an opinion.
1425386
Yes, it's much smoother. That fact, and its lighter weight are what made me choose it over cast iron. I haven't noticed any loss, or unevenness, of seasoning. I cook on a glass cooktop, by the way.
234008
I believe so. The pump is a little annoying. You don't have to have the pump on. I accidentally turn the pump off because of it's location, so that is a little annoying also. However, it is the only iron I have found that you have to option to override the auto shutoff.
2019402
I wouldn't say this pump was marine grade but if you flush it out with fresh water afterwards you should be OK. It looks like most of the pump side is cast aluminum. As other state for, the price it is hard to beat.
435997
The difference is the porcelain on the lesser expensive model vs stainless on the other.
1919180
Not sure about the difference, but the iron has worked great for me since I purchased it a few months back.
796798
I have this Dutch Oven and a similar Le Creuset. On gas ranges I prefer cast iron. For electric ranges I prefer this one in stainless. I'm buying another because I'm now cooking on electric and I'm no longer seeing them at Marshals. Just the inferior ones with welded on bottoms. Cast iron takes too long to heat on electric.
796801
It's all about what you plan to cook. If something will be cooking slow for along time you'll be better off with the cast iron. If you need a tomato sauce or 1/2 lb of spaghetti use the SS. Pro for stainless, cleans really well, much lighter, won't chip(assuming enameled cast iron)
50517
The cast iron pump cools much better: That can be an issue if it's pumping a lot when the water level is low and it's not completely immersed, or if the float switch sticks on.
50352
No, mine is stainless steel, not cast iron. Works well though, and I just put it in the dishwasher when done.
412052
It's stainless. I highly recommend this motor. It's plenty powerful and the foot control is awesome.
577180
stainless will hold up better to moisture, won't rust out. Carbon Steel is typically stronger and holds an edge longer, but needs to be treated with some sort of oil to protect the finish from the elements.
23956
I can't tell the difference in steel blends by looking at the material. I will say, like Pamela, ours is easy to clean and corrosion free after several months of daily use. My water is fairly neutral in pH, and low in salts. Given the amount of metal in the thing, I find it hard to believe the manufacturer would use an alloy that wouldn't stand up the household use.
2223661
LOL!!! I debated the same thing! Ended up going with the stainless as I thought it matched the kitchen better. No rust issues, heats up very quickly. Not too big, not too small! Just be careful the first time or two when you pick it up by the handle as certain areas on the handle can get hot. Once you get used to that, it's no issue!
245975
Hello Michael! We are happy to clarify the difference between our mills and other listing you may come across on Amazon. We offer the Original Pump & Grind mills on our Grind Gourmet Original listings, these mills differ from others you may come across, they are made of a solid stainless steel tubing verses plastic tubing the copies are made with. The copies look like the originals because the manufacturer has added a metal sleeve to cover the interior plastic cylinder. We offer our Originals in a variety of colors, sizes and style, in singles, sets and a travel variety. We have backed our product line for many years with many happy returning customers. We understand knowing the difference in quality helps to explain a pricing difference, buying from Grind Gourmet Original listings offers the very best in quality! We hope this helps.
1025243
The brushed stainless steel, in my opinion, hands down, is better looking and functioning than the chrome.