will the S4 with the Samsung Protective case on it it fit w/o having to remove the case?
818688
Depends on the case. Doesn't work on the "otter"cause of the flip back usb protector.
818689
It was very tight with the Incipio slim case. The Incipio case is a little different than most this cases. It has a hard outer shell and an inner silicone case. IF you have a traditional slim case you might be OK. I could get it into the charger with the Incipio case still on the phone but it was difficult.I think it only cost me $3 - $4 to ship it back via first class mail.I explained this to the vendor and they refunded my money as soon as they received the product that I shipped back to them.
818690
I use Spigen case and it slides in fine. This is a slim line case. The cradle gas a removable insert that allowing a slim case to slide in the drop cradle. I do like this case
818691
It depends on the case, with the diztronic case fits perfect, but whit a spigen case it won't, so you have to remove it.
667034
You will need to remove it. My husband had a slim case and he still had to remove it.
28769
I have an S4 but my case isn't the otter but it leaves plenty of room for my phone.
2052136
I believe so. My wife has an S4 with a large case, not an otter box but large, and I have a note and both fit just fine
731391
No it won't fit. The camera and flash on the s4 are right in the middle of the phone. You can look for a case for the s4 so you can understand what I'm talking about.
1264263
Don't know -- you would need to compare to the S4 for dimensions. The S4 is the only one I know it fits for sure.Lew
16155
The S4 is shaped differently. I believe, not only is it more square, but it is also larger.So not I don't think it will fit.
934964
S4 active is a bit longer and somewhat thicker then the original S4 so no its not going to fit....
1601741
The S4 is slightly bigger and has a squarer look to it. So I don't think this will fit the S4. Sorry =\
738201
It fits my s4 in a life proof case with some room to spare. It'll fit your phone
283919
Probably. My phone, without a protective case, was a tight fit at first but it stretches over time - not so much that it falls out - but just a bit from placing phone in and taking phone out. My GUESS is it would do the same with a protective case but it will be a VERY tight fit in the beginning and you will have to pry out (or use the "push" opening on the bottom) for awhile. Still love the case and still recommend.
1403243
Yes, it appears to fit well. The S4 is .2" larger in height, 1.54" smaller in depth, and .4" wider. Even so, there is plenty of room.
726193
No. It fits the S3 like a glove. The S4 has a slightly different shape and if you have a larger battery then the case won't fit.
1773934
Not sure how big a samsung galaxy s4 is but I have a Droid 4 phone with a hybrid case and it fits with plenty of room left. Hope this helps
2041538
I don't think it will fit. It seems to only have room for the phone without a case.
1513006
I have a Samsung Galaxy S4 with an Otterbox case and it fits easily into that conpartment.
1069724
I doubt it, I have the S4 and it barely fit with a case and only lasted a couple months before it broke.