Does this plastic lid keep smells in better than the s/s lid version?
797152
I'm not sure about keeping smells in. But I like it better because the garbage can stays stable while opening. On the other design, the garbage can would move back and hit the wall. This lid opens more smoothly, without moving the whole can. I liked it so much I purchased a second one for another part of the house.
97800
I believe it's the same material but a little thicker for obvious reasons. If you're concerned about smell, there is none of that cheap plastic smell.
919109
I think it does a pretty good job. I use it pretty typically, don't throw a ton of food waste in there, but some from time to time. It never smells while the lid is on. But if you open the lid for any extended amount of time when it's partially full... well... lets just say I'm glad I have the lid. So yeah, I think it does a good job for a plastic trash can of this cost.
1008749
I have had this can as my kitchen trash can for probably 10 years. Like others have said, if it's something really stinky (i.e. cantaloupe rinds, rotten tomatoes, etc.) I just take out the bag, anyway. Even a can with lid won't keep those odors contained, though. I've never noticed more smell from this than when I had the plastic cans with the lids. The other option for this can is that you could (if you were so inclined) use a Stick-Up or other air freshener on the underside of the curved lid.
1567763
If I remember correctly yes the scent does the other plastic casing does not it is worth the extra dollars still smell good in my tacoma
1557404
I've had mine for quite a while so there is no plastic smell. I don't remember if it had one in the beginning. It is pretty thick. That is one thing I liked about it.
456065
Not much difference except for the lid, which I think is a huge difference. The lid on the LitterLocker II is far superior to that of the Litter Genie. Easier to change too. It closes tighter and really keeps the odors away. I have not compared the bag cartridges and their capacities.
1414015
There is a liner inside the lid, I'm not sure if that is what you mean by a "rubber seal". The salve I store in that jar is rather pungent and it does keep that smell in.
1406979
I put round in first then square on the bottom. Don't really think it makes a difference. I'm really happy with the odor control!
1414018
The lid is tight and doesn't let odors out. I'm not sure if it's rubber exactly but it works fairly well.
2100284
I use this cover for an outdoor grill and to date have not sensed any unusual order or smell of plastic permeating from it. I would suggest this result may be caused simply because it is covering the grill outdoors, that being said even when I am close to it I do not smell any plastic type order.
284843
After use, does the lid fit tight enough to control odor? Is there such a thing as biodegradable bags?
1584040
Yes the lid is close enough to keep odors out. I love it and wouldn't consider buying another type of trash can. I am very pleased.
1643906
No odor on mine...the fit is a bit loose when I bought 7 months ago and now the edges is really giving way and dirt is getting in the sides. The only reason I bought this is the magnetic stand behind it which makes it very handy.
960667
Haven't noticed any odors as long as the lid is closed. Very happy with the one I have; we do empty our trash every day.
2242868
I don't use the lid on mine but I would think that it would contain mild odors fairly well with the lid. If I have something particularly stinky like wrapping from fish I put it in a separate plastic bag and wrap it up or get rid of the trash bag quickly. I do like this item.
578060
I assure you, PLASTIC lids WILL ABSORB and HOLD ODORS.The stainless steel can be scrubbed clean with a proper brush and soap.Even after removing the silicone gasket, scrubbing the plastic, then several soaks in hot soapy water, my lids still retain odors.One of my lids is used only for Coffee (very obvious lingering smell) and I have another that still smells a little like a citrus electrolyte drink (Pocari Sweat) that I left in the bottle for several days.I have two Hydroflasks (20 and 40oz wide-mouth bottles), with standard / flip / straw lids.If scent is an issue, you can always buy a replacement lid. I assure you, PLASTIC lids WILL ABSORB and HOLD ODORS.The stainless steel can be scrubbed clean with a proper brush and soap.Even after removing the silicone gasket, scrubbing the plastic, then several soaks in hot soapy water, my lids still retain odors.One of my lids is used only for Coffee (very obvious lingering smell) and I have another that still smells a little like a citrus electrolyte drink (Pocari Sweat) that I left in the bottle for several days.I have two Hydroflasks (20 and 40oz wide-mouth bottles), with standard / flip / straw lids.If... » Read More I assure you, PLASTIC lids WILL ABSORB and HOLD ODORS.The stainless steel can be scrubbed clean with a proper brush and soap.Even after removing the silicone gasket, scrubbing the plastic, then several soaks in hot soapy water, my lids still retain odors.One of my lids is used only for Coffee (very obvious lingering smell) and I have another that still smells a little like a citrus electrolyte drink (Pocari Sweat) that I left in the bottle for several days.I have two Hydroflasks (20 and 40oz wide-mouth bottles), with standard / flip / straw lids.If scent is an issue, you can always buy a replacement lid. « Show Less